Thursday, January 21, 2021

447. SAME TIME, NEXT YEAR. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

Ellen Burstyn, Charles Grodin.

SAME TIME, NEXT YEAR [Comedy/Romance/Two Characters] A: Bernard Slade; D: Gene Saks; S: William Ritman; C: Jane Greenwood; L: Tharon Musser; P: Morton Gottlieb, Dasha Epstein, Edward L. Schuman and Palladium Productions; T: Brooks Atkinson Theatre; 3/13/75-9/3/78 (1,453)

Ellen Burstyn.

An unassuming, well-crafted romantic comedy that had all the right ingredients for Broadway audiences of the mid-70s. It caught on at once and hung around long enough to make it the most successful straight play of the decade, running three and a half years. Its afterlife in regional and amateur productions raked in lots of additional profits. And, of course, there was the 1978 movie version, with Ellen Burstyn (of the original Broadway cast) and Allan Alda.

Its simple, but appealing, concept, arranged to have two already happily married characters, George (Charles Grodin) and Doris (Burstyn) meet one weekend in 1951 at a California resort, fall in love, spend the night in sin, and agree to get together at the hotel on the same weekend every year thereafter.  George is a New Jersey accountant, out West on a business trip. Doris, a Catholic, is at the hotel before making a planned retreat at a nearby convent.

Charles Grodin, Ellen Burstyn.

The couple’s affair takes them through 24 years of weekend encounters, in the same hotel room. The audience gets to see all the current trends in lifestyles represented by their changing clothes, language, and behavior. Six scenes show them at five-year intervals, so George and Doris’s physical changes become readily apparent in each new scene.

Same Time, Next Year was viewed as a perfectly adroit boulevard comedy, despite its basically implausible premise, and appealed to all the wishful thinkers for whom it was obviously intended. A clever combination of social satire, nostalgic reminiscence, mildly racy words and jokes, and full-blown sentimentality, it offered meaty roles for its attractive and charismatic players.

Charles Grodin, Ellen Burstyn.

Bernard Slade’s comedy was warmly recommended by John Simon, who said “it is genuinely funny, often moving, and slyly perspicacious throughout. If it does not rise into the domain of art, it at least never stoops to facile sagaciousness, obvious vulgarity, or straining for laughs.” Brendan Gill deliberately exaggerated in betting that the play would “run for twenty years.” He laughed “helplessly, all evening long.” Douglas Watt may have quibbled over the play’s slenderness, but Clive Barnes knew he had seen “the funniest comedy about love and adultery to come Broadway’s way in years. . . . Here is an old-fashioned, well-made play that is well made in a new way for new times.”

Charles Grodin and Ellen Burstyn helped turn the play into a smash hit by the excellence of their chemical connection. Edwin Wilson’s comment that “they are providing two of the most solid pieces of acting New York has seen in a comedy in some times” was representative. “Ellen Burstyn,” wrote T.E. Kalem, “glows with womanhood and the understanding of life that comes from having weathered life’s storms. Her performance has an unstrained authority and is resonant with insight.” Of her costar, Barnes declared, “His is a lopsided comic presence on stage, and he is even more consistently funny here than he was in the film The Heartbreak Kid. His comic sensitivity is so acute that he can give life to a line by a calculated waver of his voice.”

Same Time, Next Year landed a Tony nomination for Best Play and a Drama Desk Award for Best American Play. Burstyn won the Tony for her acting, and also snared a Drama Desk Award. She and Grodin shared an Outer Critics Circle Award for Outstanding Ensemble Playing, while Gene Saks received a Tony nomination as Best Director.

 

 

TRUMP TRUMP TRUMP ALONG THE BROADWAY: PART 2

Julius Caesar (Photo: Joan Marcus)

 For Part 2 of my two-part essay on how Donald Trump was treated on the New York stage during his presidency, please click on THEATER LIFE.

Wednesday, January 20, 2021

TRUMP TRUMP TRUMP ALONG THE BROADWAY. PART 1

James Badge Dale, Tamara Tunie in Building the Wall. Photo: Carol Rosegg.

For Part 1 of my article about how theatre handled the Trump presidency, please click on THEATER LIFE.



446. SALOME. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970--1975.

Lindsay Kemp.

SALOME [Dramatic Revival] A: Oscar Wilde; AD/D: Lindsay Kemp; S: Chris Sedimaur; L: David Andrews; M: William Hellerman; P: New York Theatre Ensemble i/a/w Alan Eichler and Ron Link; T: Truck and Warehouse Theatre (OB); 1/8/75-2/16/75 (30)

Scottish mime Lindsay Kemp--the Taylor Mac of his day--followed up his Broadway production of Flower with this eccentric Off-Broadway revival of Oscar Wilde’s one-act play, which the author wrote in French in 1893, years before it was allowed a public performance. Kemp, whose transvestite methods were evident in Flowers, brought a similar touch to Salome, doing it with an all-male cast. 

His attempt to conceptualize the staging began promisingly enough with an opening tableau in which the briefly-dressed company, wearing white clown makeup, stood stock still for several minutes. However, as Clive Barnes pointed out, the moment they began speaking Wilde’s words, the play flew out the window.

Kemp himself played Salomé in this travesty version of Wilde’s melodrama, but his performance was “a display rather than a characterization,” wrote Barnes. The critic also faulted the show as tedious, humorless, and bland.

Tuesday, January 19, 2021

445. SAFARI 300. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.

Tad Truesdale.
SAFARI 300 [Musical Revue] CN: Tad Truesdale; D: Hugh Gittens; CH: Lari Becham; S: Bob Olsen; C: Lee Lynn; L: David Adams; P: Richie Havens; T: Mayfair Theatre (OB); 7/12/72-7/26/72 (17)

 A stimulating revue of Black music covering hundreds of years of Black history, conceived by and starring Tad Truesdale, performed in a small, basement theatre on W. Forty-sixth Street. The 10-person company included Lari Becham, Ernest Andrews, Joyce Griffen, Holly Hamilton, Onike Lee, Fredi Orange, Andre Robinson, Grenna Whitaker, and Dorian Williams. They sang and danced spiritedly on a bare platform stage with a ramp at the rear, conveying the pain, sorrow, anger, joy, and humor of their racial experience. Popular singer-musician Richie Havens served as the producer.

The music ran the gamut from African ritual chants to slave melodies and hymns to 1920s Harlem jazz to 70s rock and rhythm ‘n blues. Howard Thompson observed that much of the show was “blazingly dynamic and alive.” He noted that Truesdale “has a voice best described as friendly. He is far more effective fitted into the ensemble numbers.”

Monday, January 18, 2021

444. A QUARTER FOR THE LADIES ROOM. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.

Norma Donaldson, Benay Venuta, Helen Blount, Judy MacMurdo, Paula Cinko.

A QUARTER FOR THE LADIES ROOM [Musical Revue/Women] LY: Ruch Batchelor; M: John Clifton and Arthur Siegel; D: Darwin Knight; S: David R. Ballou; C: Miles White; L: Lee Lawson; P: Phillip R. Productions; T: Village Gate (OB); 11/12/72 (1)

If the title of this revue doesn't immediately come to mind, that may be because it was flushed away after only a single performance. Done in a cabaret ambience with the audience seated at small cocktail tables before a tiny stage, A Quarter for the Ladies Room presented five archetypal women in an intimate performance set in a ladies room lounge. 

There was the sweet-as-pie Angel (Pauline Cinko), the attractive Mistress (Judy MacMurdo), the Black and sexy Harlot (Norma Donaldson), and the aging Wife (Benay Venuta). Helen Blount was the patient Attendant. Each unloaded her problems with men in song (there was no dialogue), but the music and lyrics, while not awful, were neither diverting nor interesting. It was well enough performed, but essentially bland. "I wouldn't give you a nickel for it," growled Mel Gussow.

Among the song titles were "First Quarter," "Turn Around," "Talk about the Men," "My Lover and His Wife," "Why Don't I Leave Him?," and "The Last Quarter."

Note: apologies for this entry being placed after the "R" postings instead of before them.

Sunday, January 17, 2021

443. THE RULES OF THE GAME. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.


Joan Van Ark.
THE RULES OF THE GAME [Dramatic Revival] A: Luigi Pirandello; TR: William Murray; D: Stephen Porter; S: Douglas Higgins; C: Nancy Potts; L: Ken Billington; P: The New Phoenix Repertory Company; T: Helen Hayes Theatre; 12/12/74-12/21/74 (12)

This rarely revived early Pirandello work (not to be confused with Jean Renoir's classic 1939 film of the same title) was presented by the New Phoenix Repertory Company in a version that intrigued somebut that others felt might have been better done. The 1918 play intrigued the critics for its treatment, not of the usual reality-versus-illusion theme of the Italian playwright’s work, but of the conflict between reason and instinct.

Silia (Joan Van Ark) is the instinctual woman, one who lives for her feelings and impulses, while her detached, intellectual husband, Leone Gala (John McMartin), lives for a life dominated by the cool forces of rationality. He shows no evidence of jealousy even when he knows his friend Guido (David Dukes) has been having an affair with Silia at the luxurious apartment he has provided for her as part of their separation agreement. Rankled by her husband’s indifference (actually a mask for his jealousy), Silia wants him to die, and contrives a situation in which he is forced to challenge to a duel a master swordsman and marksman over an alleged insult offered to Silia. Playing as he does by the “rules of the game,” Leone arranges matters so that Guido, his second, must fight the duel and thereby die in his place, a victim of what T.E. Kalem called “the deadliest rule of all: a husband’s right to kill his wife’s lover.”

John McMartin, David Dukes.

The Rules of the Game, the play being rehearsed at the start of Pirandello’s classic Six Characters in Search of an Author, proved to be a suspenseful, intellectually invigorating exercise, but the consensus was that its performance left much to be desired. According to Clive Barnes, “the acting was not quite good enough for this strangely stylized comedy of ill manners. When Mr. [Paul] Scofield played Gala [three years earlier, at London’s National Theatre], he played him with a frozen indifference and a blazing intellectuality that was almost a moral force. . . . John McMartin . . . has little of this certainty. His metallic voice charmingly bumbles on, and he is almost pathetic as a betrayed husband about to be led to his doom. . . .”

Joel Fabiani, John McMartin, Charles Kimbrough.

Harold Clurman, opining that the company simply lacked the actors to pull this play off, said that the husband’s role needed “a 40-year-old John Barrymore . . . and all the Phoenix can provide is John McMartin, a character actor best in the impersonation of clowns, weaklings and dotards.” T.E. Kalem, however, had other thoughts, pointing to "a polished cast paced by the sensitive honesty of John McMartin's performance makes the evening hum with suspense." 

Barnes added that Joan Van Ark “is perfectly admirable within [the play’s] own conventions but lacks the capricious willfulness of Pirandello's actual heroine. The only character who truly stood within the actual play was the Guido of David Dukes, half‐elegant barfly and half‐Mafia scion . . . , who wanders through the action like a somnambulist closed‐liddedly intent on some unknowing destiny—a pawn to the great playwright in the skies.” Other cast members of note included Peter Friedman, Charles Kimbrough, Ellen Tovatt, Munson Hicks, and as one of the “neighbors,” a young actress named Glenn Close.