Thursday, January 28, 2021

454. SCENES FROM AMERICAN LIFE. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.

Priscilla Pointer (center), and clockwise: Lee Lawson, Robert Symonds; Elizabeth Huddle, Christopher Walken, Herbert Foster, James Broderick, Martha Henry. Photo: Martha Swope.
SCENES FROM AN AMERICAN LIFE [Comedy-Drama/Family/Period/Politics] A: A.R. Gurney, Jr.; D: Dan Sullivan; S/L: John Scheffler; C: James Berton Harris; P: Repertory Theatre of Lincoln Center; T: Forum Theatre (OB): 3/25/71-4/18/71 (30)

A panorama, in over 30 sketches, of four decades of American life, from the Depression to  the 1970s, offering an unsettling glimpse into the future as well as a nostalgic look at the past. The cast of eight each played many roles in this satiric, but cynical, examination of the hypocrisy (sexual, religious, and social) of our society as seen through the microcosm of the lives of certain well-established families in Buffalo, New York. A piano medley of pop and classical music accompanied the action.

A considerable number of reviewers thought highly of the play, considering it among the best things ever seen at Lincoln Center's Forum. Harold Clurman called it “well-written,” and Martin Gottfried found it “mostly a lovely entertainment,” although the futurescape scenes were “trite and irrelevant,” not suited to the rest of the work. Douglas Watt termed it “as telling an entertainment as the season has produced,” and he and others touched on the author’s ability to tell his tale with generous quantities of wit. Clive Barnes opined that this “splintered view of a splintered society is effective and chilling,” but thought there was insufficient exploration of the reasons behind the issues and people. “It is never clear what they do or don’t do to deserve the fate Mr. Gurney has in store for them.” Even more on the debit side was Dick Brukenfeld’s comment that Gurney makes the “potentially disturbing . . . toothless and acceptable.”   

All agreed that the performances and direction were first-rate, with young Christopher Walken collecting several distinguished accolades. Gottfried, for instance, remarked that he “was getting better every day” and gave a “dazzling” presentation. For others in the cast, check the caption for the accompanying photo. 

Gurney proved a worthy recipient of the Drama Desk Award for Most Promising Playwright.

Wednesday, January 27, 2021

453. SCAPIN/SCAPINO (two productions). From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.


Cast of Scapin. Can you spot, say, David Ogden Stiers, Kevin Kline, and Patti LuPone?
1.

SCAPIN [Dramatic Revival] A: Molière; D: Pierre Lefevre; LY: Sam Tsoutsouvas; C: John David Ridge; L: Martin Aronstein; P: City Center Acting Company; T: Billy Rose Theatre; 1/28/73 (1)

In January 1973, Broadway saw the rapid failure of a musical called Tricks (discussed later in this series), based on Molière’s 1671 farced, Les Fourberies de Scapin. Nonetheless, the following season of 1973-1974 hosted two straight revivals of the rarely seen play, the first being this hour-long children’s theatre version given only a single performance at a special matinee during the Acting Company’s 1973-1974 repertory season on Broadway. Jared Sakren’s spirited rendition of Scapin led a lively group of actors through this buoyant romp that Mel Gussow said even seven-year-olds could follow.

That group of actors included such yet-to-make-their-mark names as Sam Tsoutsouvas, Kevin Kline, Patti LuPone, Cynthia Herman, Leah Chandler, and David Ogden Stiers.

2.

Jim Dale.

2.

SCAPINO

AD/D: Frank Dunlop; S/C: Carl Toms; L: David Watson; M: Jim Dale; P: National Theatre of Great Britain, presented by the Brooklyn Academy of Music i/a/w Brooklyn College in the Young Vic Production; T: Brooklyn Academy of Music (OB); 3/12/74-3/31/74 (10); T: Circle in the Square Joseph E. Levine Theatre; 5/19/74-8/1/74 (121): total: 122

England’s Young Vic company brought its popular updating of Molière’s play, here called Scapino, to BAM for a short rep season with two other plays, and then moved the show to a Broadway mounting at the financially strapped Circle in the Square. That venue welcomed the chance to bring in a successful, fully staged, outside show and thus defray much of the cost of producing a new show from scratch.

Gavin Reed, Jim Dale.

Frank Dunlop’s brilliantly unconventional approach mingled British music hall and commedia dell’arte techniques, with numerous references to familiar New York names and places, thereby creating a comic masterpiece that Clive Barnes considered “one of the funniest things in New York." Placed in a contemporary Naples excellently designed with pop art wit by Carl Toms, the show used every sort of zany slapstick device to provoke loud hilarity.

One choice example was a plate of spaghetti that could be tossed blithely through the air without a strand flying loose. There was continual audience interplay with lead actor Jim Dale addressing the spectators directly. Barnes said, “He chats to the audience as if they were personal friends.”

Jeremy James-Taylor, Jim Dale.

Dale was the centerpiece of the delightful ensemble. Clown, classical actor, acrobat, and musician (he wrote the score), he dazzled with his multi-skilled virtuosity in the roguish role of the comic servant. John Simon, who thought the BAM staging was better than the Broadway one, which had several cast changes, was forced to admit, “He is one of the funniest comedians I have ever seen, and if I should be granted a dying wish, it would be for a command performance by him—so I could die laughing.” Simon died last year, but I don't imagine he departed with a chuckle in his throat. Dale took away a Drama Desk Award for Outstanding Performance, as well as a Tony nomination for Best Actor, Play. Dunlop got a Drama Desk Award as Outstanding Director, and a Tony nomination for Best Director, Play.

Scapino made a return engagement at Broadway’s Ambassador Theatre in a proscenium staging (the one at Circle in the Square was in the three-quarters round) for an additional 176 performances, beginning 9/27/74 and ending 3/2/75. This brought the total number to 298 performances, with Dale remaining as star despite a number of cast changes.  

Tuesday, January 26, 2021

452. SAY WHEN. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

SAY WHEN [Musical/Period] B/LY: Keith Winter; M: Arnold Goland; D/CH: Zoya Leporska; S: William Jame Wall; C: Lelia Larmon; L: Clarke W. Thornton; P: Walter Rosen Scholz; T: Plaza 9 Theatre (OB); 12/4/72-12/9/72 (7)

Note: No photos of this production appear to be available.

“[A] little monster” of a show about a 1970s New York magazine editor recalling the good old days of the 1920s. His memories are enacted in sketches, songs, and dances. Nothing about the work pleased Clive Barnes, who attacked the “derivative” book, lyrics, and music, the uninspired staging, the “cheap” visuals, and the company, to whom he offered “condolences.”

Richard Watts considered the show “strangely flat and disappointing,” and Douglas Watt claimed it dripped “charm like a leaky bottle of perfume.” The book writer and lyricist was a once well-respected novelist and playwright and his material here was said to be semi-autobiographical.

 

Monday, January 25, 2021

451. SAVED. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.

Tom Leopold, Stefan Hartman, Don Warfield, Richard Cox.

SAVED [Drama/British/Crime/Family/Romance] A: Edward Bond; D: Alan Schneider; S/C: Eugene Lee and Franne Newman; L: Roger Morgan; P: Chelsea Theatre Center of Brooklyn; T: Chelsea Theatre, Brooklyn Academy of Music (OB); 10/28/70-1/7/70 (29)

James Woods, Margaret Braidwood.

One of the grimmest works in years, this intense British drama—laced with enough humor to keep it from being completely depressing—was the first Edward Bond play done in New York. It offered an intimate look at the sordidness and vulgarity of life among a substratum of the working classes.

The feckless Len (James Woods) and Pam (Dorrie Kavanaugh) are young people whose love affair leads to their living together in the home of Pam’s parents—neither of whom has spoken to the other in 20 years. Pam betrays Len with the sexually more appealing Fred (Kevin Conway), by whom she has a baby that Len cares for as his own. In the shocking scene that caused the play to be banned by Britain’s Lord Chamberlain when it was produced by the Royal Court Theatre in 1965, the baby is stoned to death in its carriage by Fred and his pals.

The banning raised such an outcry among artists and intellectuals that it eventually led to abolition of the official British censor, a position dating back hundreds of years. In New York, where no official censor existed, Saved stirred up a great deal of critical approval, both for its powerful substance and its illuminating production. It opened locally after two planned productions elsewhere were cancelled.

Despite its being overlong, and having an anticlimactic resolution following the stoning scene, the play disturbed few critics. Walter Kerr looked askance at it as an example of the condescension of the outsider playwright viewing with contempt the lives of those beneath him, thereby making the characters seem “subhuman.” And Harold Clurman, recognizing Bond’s gifts, asserted, “We have passed the need for this sort of realism. . . . [B]ond’s play commands more respectful assent than artistic enthusiasm.”

More widespread were encomiums such as John Lahr’s, that Saved is “distinguished . . . for the profound, riveting compassion [Bond] finds for the barren, loveless embers of humanity who are his characters.” Clive Barnes raved about this “incandescent first work,” and Martin Gottfried called it “unusually powerful.”

Alan Schneider’s direction scored only a partial triumph, the critics splitting down the middle on its effectiveness. Kevin Conway’s Fred, James Woods’s Len, and Margaret Braidwood’s Pam were exceptional within an otherwise adequate company. Braidwood landed an OBIE for Distinguished Performance, as did Woods, who also received a Vernon Rice Award.

 

Sunday, January 24, 2021

450. SATURDAY SUNDAY MONDAY. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.

William McCauley, Susan Merson, Eli Wallach.
SATURDAY SUNDAY MONDAY [Comedy/Family/Italian/Italy/Marriage] A: Eduardo de Filippo; AD: Keith Waterhouse and Willis Hall; D/DS: Franco Zeffirelli; L: Roger Morgan; P: Barry M. Brown, Fritz Holt, and S. Spencer Davids b/a/w the National Theatre of Great Britain; T: Martin Beck Theatre; 11/21/74-11/30/74 (12)

Sam Gray, Jeff Giannone, Walter Abel.

A mildly diverting comedy that came to Broadway after a successful staging at Britain’s National Theatre, with the director-designer of that production, the world famous Franco Zeffirelli, repeating his chores with an American cast. The first play to reach Broadway by prolific Italian dramatist-screenwriter-director-actor Eduardo de Filippo, it contained elements of Neapolitan farce, commedia del’arte, and the subject of a cuckolded husband, all of which are bound up in many of the writer’s works.

Sada Thompson, Sam Gray.

Zeffirelli created extremely realistic scenery for this large-cast, three-act, family comedy, which takes place in the kitchen and dining room of a well-to-do Neapolitan family. It begins on Saturday night, with the actual onstage preparation of a ragu by the matriarch, Rosa (Sada Thompson), the fragrant aroma of which pervaded the auditorium. It then shows the consumption of that concoction at a Sunday dinner peopled by numerous friends and relatives. Finally, on Monday morning, the cold leftovers are finished off.

The central action, apart from the cooking and eating, concerns a marital misunderstanding between Rosa and her spouse, Peppino (Eli Wallach). Rosa has been cool to Peppino ever since she began thinking he slighted her cooking. He, unaware of his contretemps, assumes she has been having an affair with a good-looking accountant neighbor (Ron Holgate). The problem is ironed out in the third act after a monumental verbal brawl between the couple. In the course of the play, the many charming characters surrounding the married couple are introduced, along with their subplot relationships.

Eli Wallach, Ron Holgate, Terry Hinz.

Wallach and Thompson gave their professional best to this modestly pleasing enterprise in the roles that would be played on film in 1978 by Joan Plowright and Frank Finlay (Laurence Olivier played the elderly Antonio [Walter Abel on Broadway]). The critics were tolerant of the comedy’s blandishments, but were not lavish in dispensing accolades. They questioned the uneven use of Italian dialects, the too-long, two-and-a-half hour length, and the stock characters and plot. Most agreed with Clive Barnes that it was “a perfectly agreeable boulevard comedy,” but not much more.

Though all had their reservations, only a few, like Martin Gottfried and John Simon, were truly ill-disposed toward the play and production, which lasted a mere week and a half.

Saturday, January 23, 2021

449. SANTA ANITA '42. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.

Lani Gerrie Miyazaki, Stephen D. Newman. Photo: Thomas Victor.
SANTA ANITA ’42 [Drama/Asian-Americans/Family/Period/Politics/Race/Romance] A: Allan Knee; D: Steven Robman; S: Jeremy Unger; C: Carol Odits; L: David Sackeroff; P: Chelsea Theatre Center of Brooklyn; T: Chelsea Theatre, Brooklyn Academy of Music (OB); 2/27/75-3/16/75 (32)

One of the major disgraces in American history, the internment of huge numbers of Japanese-Americans during World War II, was brought to national and world attention with increasing outrage in the 70s in books, plays, and films. The first treatment on the New York stage was this flawed drama, set largely at at California’s Santa Anita Racetrack, which was used as a detainment camp from 1942 to the war’s end.

The play focuses on the Japan-born Tamako (Lani Gerrie Miyazaki), who came to America in 1920 to marry, by arrangement, Satoru (Conrad Yama), a man much older than she. She had a son, Michael (Sab Shimono), by him. Michael grows up as the action develops across many short scenes. After he is already mature, she meets and has an affair with a white, American engineer (Stephen D. Newman), who gets her pregnant. Pearl Harbor intervenes, the family is interned, and, among other catastrophes, Michael is killed by camp guards after delivering a fiery speech denouncing American policies.

The ambiguous ending suggests either that Tamako remains to contemplate her future life or that she goes home to Japan. Throughout, she has been advised by a semi-realistic chorus-like figure, the Teacher (Henry Kaimu Bal), to adapt to life the way a Japanese garden does to its landscape.

Though well performed and directed, the play—despite evidence of writing talent—failed to handle its subject effectively, being “wispy and confusing” and never entirely clear or convincing” to Edith Oliver; lacking in “coherence” and being “simplistic” to Clive Barnes; too “slackly hung together” for Douglas Watt; “unimaginative” to Martin Gottfried; an too melodramatic for Jack Kroll.  

Friday, January 22, 2021

448. SAMMY ON BROADWAY. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.

Sammy Davis, Jr.
SAMMY ON BROADWAY [Musical Revue] D: Darrell Giddens; P: Nederlander; T: Uris Theatre; 4/23/74-5/4/74 (14)

Freda Payne.
Also called simply Sammy, this was basically a showcase for the versatile talents of singer-mimic-actor-dancer-comedian-musician Sammy Davis, Jr. As filler, the show backed him up with songstress Freda Payne and legendary tap-dance artists the Nicholas Brothers. 

The Nicholas Brothers.

“This is essentially a nightclub show with Mr. Davis as the featured act,” explained Mel Gussow. Supported by an onstage orchestra of 28, the diminutive figure of the great entertainer, seen in the wide expanses of the Uris Theatre (currently the Gershwin), appeared “tinier and even more vulnerable than ever,” thought Brendan Gill, but Davis’s enormous energy drove him through “bursts of song, dance, wry jokes, reminiscences, laments over the onset of age, tributes to friends, and stern self-exhortation.”

Dressed in black tie and tux, Davis opened with some Leslie Bricusse and Anthony Newley songs, then turned the stage over to his backup acts, and didn’t offer another number until 10:00 p.m. when he completed the show with a 45-minute routine. One tap dance was included during this sequence. The part Mel Gussow liked best was the star’s rendition of “Bojangles.”