Friday, February 19, 2021

476. SHORT EYES. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

Tito Goya, Felipe Torres.
SHORT EYES [Drama/Crime/Homosexuality/Prison] A: Miguel Pinero; D: Marvin Felix Camillo; S: David Mitchell; C: Paul Martino; L: Spencer Mosse; P: New York Shakespeare Festival; T: Public Theater/Florence S. Anspacher Theatre (OB); 2/28/74-4/14/74 (54); Vivian Beaumont Theatre; 5/23/74-8/4/74 (156) (total: 210)

Shocking for its time, Short Eyes is a nearly documentary drama of life in the dayroom of a New York City prison, written by a Puerto Rican ex-convict. It was first produced Off Broadway by a workshop group made up of other ex-cons called “The Family.” Its leader was director Marvin Felix Camillo. Joseph Papp moved it from its Off-Off mounting at the Theatre of the Riverside Church to a showing at the Public. He then startled his subscription audience at the Vivian Beaumont Theatre in the pristine surroundings of Lincoln Center, where the play's vulgar language, deviant sexual behavior, and violent action proved deeply unsettling.

Robert Maroff, H. Richard Young.

A richly ambiguous play given a brilliantly veristic interpretation by a company that practically lived the story, Short Eyes paraded a diverse assortment of prisoners across the stage. Most were Black or Hispanic, but the white convict, Murphy (Joseph Carberry), and the newly admitted Clark Davis (William Carden), an alleged child molester, were central. Murphy sides with the insecure white prisoner against the darker-skinned thugs until he learns what Davis’s crime was. 

Child molestation is considered by the inmates the worst crime possible, one that instantly makes Davis a pariah among outcasts. Only Juan (Bimbo), a saintly Puerto Rican convict, shows him any compassion, although he, too, despises this “short eyes” (slang for child molester). Ultimately, the men gang up on Davis, and Murphy slits his throat.

Joseph Carberry, William Carden.

There is never a clear-cut case against the confused “Short Eyes,” for Pinero neither definitely establishes his guilt nor denies it. Pinero’s closely observed junkies, thieves, and murderers, his realistic and profane language, his striking confrontations, and his hangman’s humor made Short Eyes one of the most respected examples of its genre.

Hollis Barnes, Bimbo, Kenny Steward, Johnny Johnson, Tito Goya, Joseph Carberry, Robert Maroff, Ben Jefferson, Felipe Torres.

“His dialogue sizzles with truth,” wrote Clive Barnes, who was enthralled by the plotting, authenticity, and honesty. According to Walter Kerr, this otherwise powerful slice of jailhouse life was too close to its sources, lacking the objectivity to view them with unimpeded artistry: “it is the fact not the form that counts.” “Every harrowing moment of it bears the stamp of passionate feeling.” But John Simon considered it “effective theatre, well put together, tightly acted, and staged with forcefulness and variety.”

Bimbo, Joseph Carberry.

A rare negative responses came from Stanley Kauffmann, who accused the play of being too similar to a host of TV, film, and theatrical works depicting life behind bars.

Short Eyes won the New York Drama Critics Circle Award and OBIE, while Miguel Pinero was given a Drama Desk Award for Outstanding New Playwright. Camillo won both an OBIE and a Drama Desk Award for his direction, while David Mitchell walked off with a Drama Desk Award for his set design.

Thursday, February 18, 2021

475. SHERLOCK HOLMES. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.

Philip Locke, John Wood. (Photos: Martha Swope.)

SHERLOCK HOLMES [Dramatic Revival] A: Arthur Conan Doyle and William Gillette; D: Frank Dunlop; S/C: Carl Toms; L: Neil Peter Jampolis; P: The Royal Shakespeare Theatre, Stratford-upon-Avon, in the Royal Shakespeare Company Production; T: Broadhurst Theatre; 11/12/74-1/4/76 (471)

Morgan Sheppard, Keith Taylor, Nicholas Selby, John Wood, Mel Martin.

An elaborate, highly successful revival of the 1899 crime melodrama in whose title role co-author William Gillette appeared on and off for 33 years. No one took the play seriously in 1974, but the cleverness of British director Frank Dunlop’s staging—he was one of the most consistently imaginative directors of the day—the gorgeousness of Carl Toms’s sets, and the acting of a thoroughly brilliant ensemble from Britain’s RSC had the critics turning cartwheels. “What a change to be able to recommend, yes, wholeheartedly, an inadequate play magnificently staged. Miraculous,” beamed Clive Barnes.

Nicholas Selby, Barbara Leigh-Hunt, John Wood, Mel Martin.

Sherlock Holmes, about an archetypal confrontation between the super-sleuth of Baker Street (John Wood, replaced by John Neville) and his masterfully dangerous archenemy, Professor Moriarty (Philip Locke, replaced by Patrick Horgan and Clive Revill), was played with all the straightforward panache required of a 19th-century thriller set in the fog-shrouded streets and book-lined lodgings of horse-and-carriage London. A touch of spoofery hung in the air, but ever so gently, never threatening to crash leadenly to the ground.

John Wood, Clive Revill.

The revolving sets were realistically and solidly built, recalling the Broadway of pre-movie years. The precision pacing, intriguingly detailed characterizations, authentically costumed characters, imaginatively conceived lighting and mood-setting violin and cello music were like a rich sundae topped by Woods’s virtuoso acting. T.E. Kalem wrote

If any of us lives to see a more perfect embodiment of Sherlock Holmes than that offered by John Wood, it will only be by some special dispensation of Thespis. . . . Wood belongs among the top dozen actors of the English-speaking stage. His voice is an organ of incisive command. He moves with the lithe, menacing grace of a puma. In an instant, he can range from partygoer prankishness to inner desolation. At the core of his being is a raging, inviolate perfectionist.

There have been, of course, more Sherlocks since this production, primarily on TV and in films. Would Kalem have revised his opinion had he seen, for instance, Benedict Cumberbatch? (Let’s leave Robert Downey, Jr., out of the convo, shall we?)

The large company also included Barbara Leigh-Hunt, Nicholas Selby, Mel Martin, Trevor Peacock, and Tim Pigott-Smith, all of whom were replaced during the run.

Wood was nominated for a Best Actor, Play, Tony, but lost to John Kane and Winston Ntshona who shared the award for Sizwe Banzi Is Dead and The Island. Locke also received a nomination, for Best Supporting Actor. Carl Toms won both the Tony for Best Scenic Designer and the comparable award from the Drama Desk. Lighting designer Neil Peter Jampolis also took home both a Tony and a Drama Desk Award

 

 

Wednesday, February 17, 2021

474. SHENANDOAH. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.


John Cullum, David Russell, Joseph Shapiro, Donna Theodore, Joel Higgins, Ted Agress, Penelope Milford, Gordon Halliday.
SHENANDOAH
[Musical/Family/Period/War] B: James Lee Barrett, Peter Udell, and Philip Rose; M: Gary Geld; LY: Peter Udell; SC: James Lee Barrett’s screenplay, Shenandoah; D: Philip Rose; CH: Robert Tucker; S: C. Murawski; C: Pearl Somner, Winn Morton; L: Thomas Skelton; P: Philip Rose, Gloria and Louis K. Sher; T: Alvin Theatre; 1/7/75-8/7/77 (1,050)

John Cullum, Donna Theodore.

Screenwriter James Lee Barrett participated in the crafting of the book for this hit musical version of his eponymous 1965 James Stewart film. First staged at Connecticut’s Goodspeed Opera House, Shenandoah struck most New York critics as an old-fashioned musical (Howard Kissell called it “simpleminded” and Martin Gottfried thought it “corny”), a kind of ersatz Rodgers and Hammerstein, which did not, however, hinder it from a long run.

John Cullum, Penelope Milford.

Set at the time of the Civil War, it follows the adventures of pacifist Virginia farmer Charlie Anderson (John Cullum in a career-defining performance) and his family, living in the Shenandoah Valley. Charlie, opposed to allowing his six sons to get involved in the conflict, suddenly finds himself enmeshed in it when his youngest, Robert (Joseph Shapiro), is kidnapped by Union soldiers. Leaving his daughter, Jenny (Penelope Milford), eldest son, James (Joel Higgins), and James's wife, Anne (Donna Theodore), on the homestead, he and his other sons go off in search of the missing child, wreaking havoc on Union trains wherever they go. Finally, after Anne, James, and another son, Jacob (Ted Agress), have been slain, the defeated Charlie comes home and, with his remaining brood, goes to church. There, the ragged little Robert comes limping in as the congregation sings a rousing hymn.

This sentimental, but certainly moving, tale was told in episodic scenes incorporating music ranging “from hymns to lullabies to country tunes to love songs to elegiac meditations,” wrote Jack Kroll. It was danced in a pre-Agnes DeMille style of thumbs tucked in overalls with lots of vigorous knee and thigh-slapping and hollering. Several critics approved the moral fervor of the show and its attempted return to an American musical method exemplified by classics such as Oklahoma!, but few were wholeheartedly supportive of it.

John Cullum and company.

Kroll argued that it was not simply a schmaltzy show, but a decent stab at making a musical out of “simple, clear, strong blocks of human feeling.” Its major flaw, he felt, was an intellectual frailty. Clive Barnes also considered it relatively successful: “it is nice to have a show around that not only dares to be tuneful but is even willing to throw in a morsel of moral uplift.” “In spite of yourself you get a catch in the throat,” added Edwin Wilson. Although T.E. Kalem admitted that it was “all sentimentally endearing,” he pointed out that “it marks one giant step backward for the American musical.” “It’s all so cornshuckingly, fingerlickingly, hornswogglingly folksy,” snapped John Simon, “that any stomach unturned by it can be sold as show leather.”

Choice targets were what Gottfried dubbed the “crude book,” or what Douglas Watt labeled the “dumb story,” not to mention the “insipid” songs. Barnes noted that the film, because of its expanded scope, told the story more potently, an advantage not challenged by the undistinguished staging. Howard Kissel claimed that the design gave the show the air of “a high-school pageant.”

Songs included “Raise the Flag of Dixie,” “I’ve Heard It All Before,” “Pass the Cross to Me,” “Next to Lovin’ I Like Fightin’,” “Over the Hill,” “Meditation” “Violets and Silverbells,” “Papa’s Gonna Make It Alright,” and “The Only Home I Know,” among others.

There was little negative response to the performances. As Charlie, John Cullum came into his own as a Broadway musical leading man. Kroll thought he had “probably the best singing voice on the American stage.” Barnes said he “can even make partially convincing some maudlin conversations with the grave of his wife, and the warmth, tone and characterization of his voice are exemplary.” Simon, however, thought “his acting is all Broadway commonplaces.”

Shenandoah was a relatively rare example of hit musical that managed to overcome tepid reviews to run for over 1,000 performances. It also garnered much official recognition, gaining Tony nominations for Best Musical, Best Book, Best Score, Best Supporting Actress (Donna Theodore), and Best Choreography. Cullum took home the Tony for Best Actor, Musical, as well as an Outer Critics Circle Award for Distinguished Performance. Chip Ford, who played Gabriel, an African-American child, received an Outer Critics Circle Award for Notable Performance by a Young Player. And Donna Theodore won the Drama Desk Award for Outstanding Featured Actress in a Musical, the first person to receive this recognition, as previous Drama Desk Awards did not differentiate between the sexes or whether a performance was in a play or musical.


 

Tuesday, February 16, 2021

473. SHELTER. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.

Joanna Merlin, Susan Browning, Marcia Rodd, Terry Kiser.

SHELTER [Musical/Advertising/Marriage/Romance] B/LY: Gretchen Cryer; M: Nancy Ford; D: Austin Pendleton; CH: Sammy Bayes; S/C: Tony Walton; L: Richard Pilbrow; P: Richard Fields and Peter Flood; T: John Golden Theatre; 2/6/73-3/3/73 (31)

Terry Kiser, Marcia Rodd.

This was the type of musical critics described with words like “likable,” “amiable,” “pleasing,” and “engaging,” as if it were a puppy, not a show. It concerns a philandering young TV ad writer named Michael (Terry Kiser) who sees his wife and seven adopted kids only on weekends, and resides during the week in the special effects set used for the commercials he creates. With him is Arthur, a marvelous computer that, at the touch of a button, can created projected scenic backgrounds appropriate for any mood or climate desired. (This prescient notion is now common in both theatre and on TV.) Arthur can also do a host of other useful feats, including singing many of the show’s songs.

Michael seduces a young actress, Maud (Marcia Rodd), is disturbed the next morning by another of his bed friends, a cleaning woman named Wednesday November (Susan Browning), and finally must face his supportive, understanding, but firm, wife, Gloria (Joanna Merlin).

There were some decidedly effective ideas in play here (many of them scenic and technical), and the performances were bright and amusing. However, the critics were mostly disappointed, opining that the show failed to come together in a consistent blend.

Clive Barnes liked the “generally neat” lyrics, and found the “undemanding soft-rock [music] with lots of electronic sound . . . attractive.” Douglas Watt said the book was “gratingly mannered and senseless,” the lyrics “foolish,” and “The music in no better.” Martin Gottfried described Shelter as “an unmusical and an undramatic play.” Several others were annoyed by the unpleasant character of the spoiled, unstable, womanizing hero. One or two felt that a more positive women’s lib approach might have helped.

Creators Cryer (mother of actor Jon Cryer) and Ford, pathbreakers in being, reportedly, the first female lyricist-composer team on and Off-Broadway, would bounce back five years later (1978) with their best-known show, the popular I’m Getting My Act Together and Taking It on the Road.

Monday, February 15, 2021

472. SHE STOOPS TO CONQUER. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.

Jane Connell, Tom V.V. Tammi, Arlene Nadel, Louis G. Trapani. (Photos: Paul H. Hoeffler)

SHE STOOPS TO CONQUER [Dramatic Revival] A: Oliver Goldsmith; D: Gene Feist; S: Holmes Easley; C: Mimi Maxmen; L: Robert Murphy; P: Roundabout Repertory Company; T: Roundabout Theatre (OB); 4/25/71-5/30/71 (36)

Jane Connell, Fred Stuthman.

This was a moderately effective revival of Goldsmith’s 1773 town and country comedy—a satire of the era’s sentimental comedy style—about deceptions practiced in a country home. The chief victim of the foolery is Young Marlowe (Robert G. Murch), who is convinced by Kate Hardcastle (Nancy Reardon) that her home is an inn and she a serving wench. The Roundabout’s 1971 production (done in an intimate basement theatre) is not to be confused with the company’s 1984 revival in a larger venue, with a different cast and director.

Jack Kroll enjoyed it enough to say, “With revivals like this, who needs new plays?” Mel Gussow considered the production “surprisingly good,” with only a few “weaknesses,” among which were “an uneven acting company, [and] a barrage of accents.” Gene Feist’s staging was adept and the period flavor appropriate, but “the true character values are squashed, squelched and suppressed,” Gussow added. There was also an unfortunate busyness to the production, including too much “unfunny and irrelevant” business. Holmes Easley’s set, though, was anything but busy, being little more than two straight-backed chairs, with the visual emphasis placed on Mimi Maxmen’s sumptuous period costumes.

Jane Connell, fighting hard to separate herself from the indelible image she created as Agnes Gooch in Auntie Mame, was “inspired” casting in the secondary but fruitful role of Mrs. Hardcastle, wrote Gussow. “Somehow, in the course of her years of playing contemporary comedy, she has become a first-rate classical character actress. She strides through this production with grace and confidence, never playing for laughs, but getting most of them. Tricked into getting lost on her own property . . . , she explodes—not into a screech of self-pity, but into a quiet rumble. When she softly moans, ‘I shall remember the horse-pond as long as I live,’ one knows that she will.”

Others in the cast included Fred Stuthman as Mr. Hardcastle, Louis G. Trapani as Tony Lumpkin, Philip Campanella as the comic servant Diggory, Arlene Nadel as Miss Neville, and, among others, Tom V.V. Tammi as Hastings.

 

Sunday, February 14, 2021

471. SHAY DUFFIN AS BRENDAN BEHAN. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.

Shay Duffin.
SHAY DUFFIN AS BRENDAN BEHAN [Solo/Biographical/Irish/Literarature] AD: Shay Duffin; SC: Writings of Brendan Behan; D: Dennis Hayes; S: Shay Duffin, Joe Behan; L: Joe Behan; P: Signature Productions; T: Abbey Theatre (OB); 1/2/73-3/18/73 (89)

A one-act show with Irish actor Shay Duffin as the rowdy, bawdy, alcoholic pub-crawling Irish poet and playwright Brendan Behan (1923-1964), who died too young to have left an extensive literary legacy. Selections from Behan’s writings and songs were offered by a husky actor who barely resembled the late writer, but whose affection for him came through in the effective choices and arrangements of the presentation. As Mel Gussow observed, “Shay Duffin . . . does not look like Behan—as, for example, Niall Toibin did', exactly, in the stage adaptation of Borstal Boy.” Duffin’s performance was “adequate,” wrote Edith Oliver, even “amiable,” to quote Gussow, but nothing special.

Duffin played the piece as though Behan were regaling the audience from a seat in a favorite pub, and he drank healthy draughts of stout throughout the evening. On opening night, at least, stout was also served to audience members. He moved into his own person occasionally, but would quickly resume the Behan impersonation. Said Gussow, “This stage Behan reveals himself as an earthy, roguish sort who cannot resist a bad joke, and who often makes up a good one. More than occasionally, he sings a lyric, such as 'There's no place on earth like the world.' Duffin's voice is good, and so is the accordion accompaniment of Barney McNelis.”

This was only one of several similar one-man shows in which actors portrayed the Irish writer, most recently 2013’s Brendan at the Chelsea.

Saturday, February 13, 2021

470. THE SHADOW OF A GUNMAN. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.

Bruce French, John Heffernan.
THE SHADOW OF A GUNMAN [Dramatic Revival] A: Sean O’Casey; D: Philip Minor; S: Lloyd Burlingame; L: Fred Allison; P: Norman Kean and John Heffernan; T: Sheridan Square Playhouse (OB); 2/29/72-4/30/72 (72)

This revival of O’Casey’s 1923 tragicomic satire on the response of a diverse group of Dublin tenement dwellers to the Irish-British political strife of 1920 was received with attitudes ranging from warm to chilly. Responses ranged from positive to reserved, a major problem being the lack of a strong ensemble and consistently effective brogues.

Clive Barnes and Harold Clurman were supportive, the former calling the show “a handsome revival” and its acting “very sound,” with “the authentic Irish lilt.” Clurman rated it “the best acted” of the three versions he had seen. Douglas Watt termed the revival “creditable,” while Edith Oliver was bothered by the shaky dialects; still the play came “through unimpeded.” John Simon and Arthur Sainer, however, ranked it as “a poor production.”

Star and co-producer John Heffernan, playing Seamus Shields, was liked by several, but turned down by the majority, while Bernard Frawley, a native-born Irishman, gained kudos for his Mr. Gallagher. Others on hand included Leon Russum as Donal Davoren, Joseph Daly as Mr. Maguire, James Carruthers as Mr. Mulligan, Bruce French as Tommy Owen, Jacqueline Coslow as Minnie Powell, Paddy Croft as Mrs. Henderson, Estelle Owens as Mrs. Grigson, and James Gallery as Adolphus Grigson.