Monday, March 1, 2021

485. SLEUTH. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

Keith Baxter, Anthony Quayle.

SLEUTH [Comedy-Drama/British/Mystery/Two-Characters] A: Anthony Schaffer; D: Clifford Williams; S/C: Carl Toms; L: William Ritman; P: Helen Bonfils, Morton Gottlieb, and Michael White; T: Music Box Theatre; 11/12/70-10/13/73 (1,222)

Anthony Quayle, Keith Baxter.

Sleuth was one of the biggest straight-play hits of the decade, although it was the first  by Anthony Shaffer, twin brother of Peter (Equus, Amadeus, etc.). Its premiere had been at England's Theatre Royal, Brighton.

A spoof of the Agatha Christie school of whodunits, it has a serious underside as well. As Shaffer explained it, “The subtext is nightmarish. The whole idea of people committed to a games situation. They’re fairly sinister people. If there is a focal point, it’s that if people take fantasy for reality, and act upon it, it must end in disaster.”

For the majority of critics the play was capable of being enjoyed as a fine example of the very genre it lightly satirized. In T.E. Kalem’s words, it is “a flawless murder mystery, . . . urbanely clever, unashamedly literate, clawingly tense and playfully savage. If it is not the best play of its genre ever, it is neck and neck with the best.”

Keith Baxter, Anthony Quayle.

The action occurs in the manorial British home (packed with bizarre props) of middle-aged mystery writer Andrew Wyke (Anthony Quayle), to which comes Milo Tindle (Keith Baxter), a young travel agent and the secret lover of Wyke’s wife. The pair engage in a prolonged battle of wits that constitutes the essential plot. Trick upon trick is played by one upon the other, and the audience is as much the dupe as are the men themselves. Elaborate costume and makeup disguises constitute one important part of the charm. The listing of several additional character and actor names in the program is designed to further confuse the theatregoer. Sleuth is one of those plays where the management requests you not to divulge the ending to your friends.

Anthony Quayle.

Clive Barnes appreciated it as “one of the most purely entertaining plays of many a season,” but a few, like Harold Clurman, while recognizing its skill, found it not meaty enough for their tastes. John Simon acknowledged the pure cleverness with which “this superficially most enjoyable play” was constructed, and delighted in the author’s “outrageous verbal facility [taken] to its witty, irreverent, rococo extreme,” but Burton Supree was offended by Sleuth’s “sledgehammer school of acting and wit,” and walked out at the break.

Sleuth is a tour de force opportunity for its stars, providing Baxter and Quayle, both distinguished British actors, with the makings for what Simon deemed “unabashedly, gloriously theatrical performances.” Barnes commented: “Mr. Quayle, grizzled, quizzical and outrageously eccentric, plays a man given to jokes, with a pleasantly grim, slightly paranoid seriousness. Mr. Baxter, urgent, hysteric and, at times rather easily scared, matches Mr. Quayle point for point until death does them part, or tries to.”  

Quayle was succeeded by Paul Rogers, George Rose, and Patrick Macnee, while Baxter’s successors were Brian Murray, Donal Donnelly, Jordan Christopher, and Curt Dawson. An idea of the acting competition the play establishes can be gained by recalling that the stars of the 1972 movie version were Laurence Olivier and Michael Caine, one at the peak of an amazing career and the other, much younger, on a trajectory to comparable success.

Sleuth walked off with the Tony for Best Play; Baxter won both an Outer Critics Circle Award and a Drama Desk Award; Quayle did likewise; Clifford Williams copped a Tony nomination for his direction; and William Ritman snared the Tony for his lighting.

 

Sunday, February 28, 2021

484. SLEEP. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

Don Fellows, Verona Barnes, Dorrie Kavanaugh, David Spielberg, Barton Heyman, Norman Bush, Conard Fowkes. (Photos: Martha Swope.)
SLEEP [Comedy-Drama/Hospital/Nudity/Race/Science] A: Jack Gelber; D: Jacques Levy; S: Kert Lundell; C: Willa Kim; L: Roger Morgan; P/T: American Place Theatre (OB); 2/10/72-3/11/72 (32)

Gil (David Spielberg) is a young man, an average guy, who is experiencing various personal difficulties at home and work. He volunteers to be a paid participant in a sleep research lab where he is placed in a bed and allowed to dream. As he sleeps his dreams come to life are enacted by him and four Black and white actors who portray his dream figures.

Gil’s emotional, marital, sexual, and employment crises are shown, none of them especially unusual. The doctors frequently wake him to pump him with questions, most of them apparently innocuous. In one scene, a Black mugger dreamed of by Gil forces him to strip, and Gil dances in the nude, enjoying his liberation. At the end, playwright Jack Gelber leaves us with “The implication . . . that man’s mind always remains basically unsusceptible to precise investigation,” as Clive Barnes explained it.

What Michael Smith called a “soporific” work was not received with open arms, Walter Kerr referring to its “portentous remarks . . . and embarrassingly literal visual metaphors,” and Barnes to its having a “concept . . . a great deal better than the play itself.” 

Saturday, February 27, 2021

483. SLAG. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

Kathryn Walker, Margo Ann Berdeshevsky, Roberta Maxwell.
SLAG [Comedy-Drama/British/Homosexuality/Politics/Women] A: David Hare; D: Roger Hendricks Simon; S: Daisy Page Pickman; C: Milo Morrow; L: Robert Kellogg; P: New York Shakespeare Festival; T: Public Theater/Other Stage (OB); 2/21/71-3/21/71 (32)

David Hare, who became one England’s most respected dramatists, was only 23 when Slag made its New York debut. It presents three teachers at Brackenhurst, an upper-class girl’s school on the skids with less than a dozen students still enrolled. The neurotic anxieties of the three are played off against each other; two, Elise (Margo Ann Berdeshevsky) and Ann (Kathryn Walker), appear to have lesbian tendencies, while the third, Joanne (Roberta Maxwell), the headmistress, is a rabid feminist. Their dialogue is often cast in long, rhetorical speeches, which sparked charges of overwriting and verbosity.  Fortunately, the burden was lightened by numerous stingingly comic remarks.

The critics reacted cautiously, most feeling Hare showed promise, but considering his play vague. Clive Barnes averred that it was filled “with more ideas than his thought can handle.” A variety of topical targets were aimed at, especially the political state of England, the title itself suggesting the residue of the past on which the nation was standing.

Edith Oliver laughed at Hare’s “eccentric notions, . . . funny lines, [and] wry outlook.” Walter Kerr may have found Slag “quite the dullest evening in town,” but Harold Clurman said, “the impression made, besides that of political muddle, is one of frenzy, verbose confusion of mind and spirit, a considerable gift for acid humor, and above all, roiling impotence.”

Canadian-born Roberta Maxwell got top honors in this well-acted production. Barnes enthused, “Such a good actress, restrained when she could have been strident, impassioned when she could have been petulant, the shining Miss Maxwell is a joy in a role that could have been written for her.” Her performance was honored with a Drama Desk Award.

Friday, February 26, 2021

482. SIZWE BANZI IS DEAD. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

John Kani, Winston Ntshona.
SIZWE BANZI IS DEAD [Drama/Politics/Race/South Africa] A: Athol Fugard, John Kani, and Winston Ntshona; D: Athol Fugard; S: Stuart Wurtzel; C: Bill Walker; L: Ronald Wallace; P: Hillard Elkins/Lester Osterman Productions/Bernard Delfont/Michael White b/a/w The English Stage Company, Ltd., in the Royal Court Theatre Production; T: Edison Theatre; 11/13/74-5/18/75 (52)

A two-man drama “devised” as a collaborative effort by South Africa’s greatest playwright, Athol Fugard, and two Black countrymen of his, John Kani and Winston Ntshona, with the latter pair’s improvisations used as the basis of plot and dialogue. It played in repertory with The Island, a similarly created work. Both plays came to Broadway after a successful stay at London’s Royal Court Theatre.

These were political plays reflective of the crushing agony endured by millions of South African Blacks under the burden of apartheid. The creators were all members of a Port Elizabeth drama troupe, the Serpent Players, founded in 1961.

A gripping, if slow moving, 45-minute monologue spoken by Styles (Kani) opens the work, as he comments, in a seeming improvisation, on newspaper headlines and recounts the story of how he had progressed from a Ford motor plant assembly line to an entrepreneur with his own little photography studio in Port Elizabeth. Part of the monologue requires participation from several audience members. Styles is interrupted by the arrival of a customer, Sizwe Banzi (Ntshona), a Black man from a small country town, who has come to the city to find work so he can support his family back home.

At first Sizwe says he wants a photo to send to his wife and children. As the play progresses, we learn via flashback that his need for the photo is for another reason. Having realized that his identification passbook contains a stamp making his continued presence in Port Elizabeth illegal, he conspires with a friend, Buntu (Kani, again), to steal the passbook of a dead man they have come across and to assume his identity and job. Sizwe wants Styles to take a photo that he can place in the dead man’s passbook.

Though the play took some time to get going, it gradually grew more and more involving, “and the sheer dramatic force of the piece bounced around the theatre like angry thunderbolts of pain,” declared Clive Barnes. There were very strong encouragements voiced for the incisive indictment of South Africa’s inhumane policies whereby a man is reduced to no more than a number and a passbook, yet where men like Styles and Sizwe Banzi continue to uphold the principles of human pride and dignity.

Both Kani and Ntshona received accolades for their full-bodied portrayals; they even shared the Tony for Best Actor, Play (for both this play and The Island). Here is Harold Clurman on their contributions:


The acting is the word become flesh; we are hardly able to differentiate between text and performances. John Kani, in both instances, plays the ‘leader,” the more knowledgeably articulate one; Winston Ntshona the more naively puzzled one. Kani is all driving impulse, which might render him breathless if he were not propelled by extraordinary energy. . . . The effect of his passion is joyful. It inspires confidence, not only in but in mankind itself.

 

Ntshona is charming in his confusion; though he must struggle to understand, we are sure that his instincts will lead to the right action. Technically he is more of a character actor than Kani, but his characterizations spring spontaneously from his inner being, so his effects are as natural as Kani’s. Both these men have acted together since their boyhood. They are now more than a term; together they have become emblematic of a people. Such acting carries primitive force; it is clear, sharp, seemingly free of any “aesthetic” premeditation. 

The play itself was Tony nominated, as was Fugard for Best Director, Play (including The Island).

 

Thursday, February 25, 2021

481. 6 RMS RIV VU. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

.
Jane Alexander, Jerry Orbach. (Photos: Friedman-Abeles, Secunda/Zarmati.)
6 RMS RIV VU [Comedy/Marriage/Romance] A: Bob Randall; D: Edwin Sherin; S: William Ritman; C: Ann Roth; L: Marc B. Weiss; P: Alexander H. Cohen and Bernard Delfont; T: Helen Hayes Theatre; 10/17/72-5/19/73 (247)

Jerry Orbach, Jane Alexander.

A moderately successful rom-com that reminded various reviewers of a typical Neil Simon play. It became a regular visitor at stock and dinner theatres for years. Its simple situation involves an attractive man, Paul Friedman (Jerry Orbach), and woman, Anne Miller (Jane Alexander), each married to someone else, who meet while examining an Upper West Side apartment for rent. They get locked in by accident when the super (Joe Ocasio) removes the doorknob, thinking the place empty. Naturally, they fall for each other, but eventually decide to return to their respective spouses.

Jane Alexander, Ron Harper, Jennifer Warren, Jerry Orbach.

The strange title refers to the abbreviated real estate listing of the sort then common in newspapers (six rooms, river view). Bob Randall’s comedy had many funny gag lines, but most critics found it eventually grew tiresome, lacking enough wit and invention to keep the plot’s wheels turning for very long.

Jerry Orbach.

The characters were “unbearably dull” to Douglas Watt, and T.E. Kalem found them, like the play, somewhat undernourished. Cast members included Ron Harper as Anne’s husband, Jennifer Warren as Paul’s wife, and, in the brief role of “Expectant Father,” F. Murray Abraham. The 1974 TV movie starred Carol Burnett and Alan Alda.

Francine Beers, Jerry Orbach.

Despite its slightness, Richard Watts liked the play’s “humor, freshness, and charm,” and Martin Gottfried believed it a “perfectly charming entertainment, sexy, romantic and funny.” For most, Orbach and Alexander provided just the right touches to help the piece keep its head above water for the better part of the season. Clive Barnes captured their contributions:

Mr. Orbach has a strangled grace, a way of hesitating in midthought, and a special awkwardness that could only have been brought on by a severe attack of adolescent acne. He is perfect in this role of an advertising copywriter who is wondering whether there is just a little more to life than advertising copy. And in Jane Alexander he finds the ideal match. Miss Alexander, hiding behind dark glasses and beneath floppy hats on her way to an unlooked‐for middle age, is sensitive, vulnerable and oddly realistic.

Alexander received a Tony nomination, Randall got a Drama Desk Award as Most Promising Playwright, and Jennifer Warren won a Theatre World Award.

Jerry Orbach, Jane Alexander.

 

Wednesday, February 24, 2021

FEBRUARY 24 IN THE 1930S: ON THIS DAY IN NEW YORK THEATER

Poster for movie version of Love on the Dole.

For the latest installment in my series, ONTHIS DAY IN NEW YORK THEATER, please click on Theater Life.

480. SIX. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

Alvin Ing, Lee Beery, Johanna Albrecht, Gilbert Price, Gail Nelson, Hal Watters.
SIX [Musical Revue] B/M/LY: Charles Strouse; D: Peter Coe; S: Richard Nelson; P: Slade Brown; T: Cricket Playhouse (OB); 4/12/71-4/18/71 (8)

Six talented young performers –Johanna Albrecht, Lee Beery, Alvin Ing, Gail Nelson, Gilbert Prie, and Hal Watters—were trapped in this Off-Broadway show. Obviously, it had no connection to the Covid-delayed, much anticipated arrival on Broadway of the identically titled British musical about the wives of Henry VIII. (The most noteworthy performer in the six-member cast was baritone Gilbert Price, who earned three Tony nominations.)

Six was an ill-fated revue in which various topical subjects were sung about in a presentation that lasted not much more than an hour. As Edith Oliver expressed it, librettist, composer, and lyricist Charles Strouse—creator of such hits as Bye Bye Birdie, Applause, and Annie—put too strong a reliance on “abstract thought” when dealing with subjects like “life, love, birth and death.”

Clive Barnes found Strouse’s lyrics “simplistic, the tone pretentious, and the music unoriginal.” He observed:

The lyrics make such commendable statements as: “Life is to Live. Life is to die. Life is to sing. Life is to cry.” Right on, baby—tell it as it is. There are some decently simplistic political comments such as: “The white man kills the Indian. Hitler kills the Jew.” And a few social meanderings such as: “Everyone's a suicide—it is just a question of when.” Well, yes.

For those old enough to remember a certain TV critic of yore, Barnes’s conclusion might be worth a gander:

Strangely, for me the most dramatic figure of the evening was my colleague Stewart Klein—he works on one of those TV channels — stolidly chewing gum in the front row. That man chews superbly. It could almost be set to music.

The Cricket, in case you're wondering, was located at 162 Second Avenue, between E. 10th and E. 11th Streets.