Sunday, March 7, 2021

492. SOLITAIRE/DOUBLE SOLITAIRE. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

Richard Venture. (Photos: William L. Smith)

SOLITAIRE/DOUBLE SOLITAIRE [Drama/One-Acts/Family] A: Robert Anderson; D: Arvin Brown; S: Kert Lundell; C: Lewis Rampino; L: Ronald Wallace P: Gilbert Cates, Roy N. Nevans, and Albert J. Schiff; John Golden Theatre; 9/30/71-10/31/71 (36)

“Solitaire” [Science-Fiction/Sex]; “Double Solitaire” [Marriage/Sex]

Will Fenno, Richard Venture, Patricia Pearcy.

Previously staged at New Haven’s Long Wharf Theatre and at the Edinburgh Festival in Scotland, these two one-acts by a respected dramatist (Tea and Sympathy, for one) generated little excitement on Broadway. Some, like Harold Clurman, thought them Robert Anderson’s “weakest work.” Though “thoughtful and provocative,” according to Richard Watts, they were, concluded Douglas Watt, “[A] pair of cheerless” plays. Feeling likewise was Martin Gottfried, who deemed the plays “irrelevant.”

The curtain raiser, “Solitaire,” is set in a Huxley-Orwellian automated future where human communication is limited to impersonal means, where love and sex as humans have known them do not exist (sperm banks are compulsory), and where a man may purchase from whorehouse equivalents the illegal pleasure of hiring an illusory family unit for an evening of old-time togetherness, sans sexual relations. The central figure, Sam Bradley (Richard Venture), earns his living by recording books for the coming illiterate generations. A widower with memories of happier days, he chooses to spend an evening in such simulated company before he dies.

This futuristic vision offered “no fresh insights,” insisted Clurman: “It does not startle, depress, excite, or amuse.” Aware of the play's faults, Julius Novick nonetheless pointed to its being “clever and well made” and its “few moments of real poignance.”

The stronger piece, “Double Solitaire,” is about contemporary married life. It seemed to Watts more like “a symposium on marriage than a dramatic treatment of its pros and cons.” Walter Kerr admired Anderson’s veracity, but was unhappy with his failure to take a stance or attitude toward the material that would illuminate the characters and ideas. “There is something limited about his insights,” put in Novick; “ordinariness is not only his strength but also his weakness. . . . I think of him as the good gray playwright.”

“Double Solitaire” concerns two couples confronted by failing marriages. O ne couple, the Potters (Ruth Nelson and John Cromwell), has been together for 50 years; the other, their son, Charley (Richard Venture), and daughter-in-law, Barbara (Joyce Ebert), for 23. A third pair, the son of the younger couple (Will Fenno) and his live-in girlfriend (Martha Schlamme), are also introduced. The central conflict is about the middle-aged pair and the state of their romantic and sexual feelings for one another.

Ruth Nelson.

The characters were too self-analytical, complained Clurman, and tiresome. There was little here above the level of “your average TV talk show,” claimed John Simon. But Clive Barnes, despite being annoyed by the “too glib” writing, said Anderson “seems to hit harder and truer than he has ever done.”

Joyce Ebert, Richard Venture.

On the whole, the acting was expert, with extra fine work turned in by Venture, Cromwell, and Ebert.  Patricia Pearcy and William Swetland were also in the cast.

 

 

Saturday, March 6, 2021

491. THE SOLDIER. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

Gregory Trigani, Paula Maliandi, Tom Kindle.
THE SOLDIER [Drama/Family/Mental Illness/Romance/Vietnam/War] A: Nick Bellitto; D: Eleanore Chapin; S: Richard Ferrugio; L: O.B. Lewis; P: The Apeiron Company; T: Provincetown Playhouse (OB); 4/10/73-4/18/73 (8)

A mediocre drama on a commonplace 70s subject, the problems of the returning Vietnam vet. Johnny DiCeasar (Tom Kindle) returns a hero, his parents smother him with affection, and his girlfriend, Susan (Paula Maliandi [shout out!]), is happy to have him back. However, he soon learns that Susan and his brother, Barry (Gregory Tigani), have been lovers, a fact known to his parents but one they were afraid to divulge. He loses his job, becomes a heavy drinker, and suffers guilty nightmares about the killing he did in Vietnam. After various frustrations, he loses his mind, brands his parents as monsters, and is taken away to a mental institution. 

According to Clive Barnes, the play suffered from a lack of originality, “imagination,” and “insight,” despite its being “sincere and even serious.” It contained evidence of craft . . . both construction and writing,” but, to Richard Watts, it was “overwrought and heavy-handed.” He found the evening one of “tiresome lugubriousness.” Douglas Watt detected “a genuine feeling of pity” that redeemed the work from total failure; otherwise it was clumsily pasted together and directed.”

Regarding the performances, Barnes added, “This low‐keyed domestic tragedy . . . has a very alert and promising performance by Tom Kindle as the returning soldier. Of the rest, Sam Locante can be singled out for his performance as the much‐troubled father.”


Friday, March 5, 2021

490. THE SOFT CORE PORNOGRAPHER. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

Dick Latessa, Dorrie Kavanaugh, Frank Raiter.
THE SOFT CORE PORNOGRAPHER [Comedy/Advertising/Marriage] A: Martin Stone and John Heller; D: Word Baker; S: Ed Wittstein; C: Caley Summers; L: David F. Segal; P: Ivan Mars; T: Stage 73 (OB); 4/11/72 (1)

A husband, Arthur Comfort (Dick Latessa), and wife, Grace (Dorrie Kavanaugh), living in a trailer in New Jersey, are having a disagreement about whether he should continue writing soft core porno novels or turn to writing a book about her family. Their neighbor, an advertising man, Trenton Corbett (Frank Raiter), is convinced he can make the husband a successful writer. When the shy husband’s writing lands him a Time cover, his wife impersonates him for the interview.

This one-night, three-character disaster was scuttled by Clive Barnes as “the kind of evening where they should dress the ushers in leather, [and] provide them with whips, and then everyone would know what they were getting.” The playwrights, he added, simply did “not possess the writing talent that might have allowed them to have exploited their original idea” of satirizing the power of the mass media to sell inferior goods. “The play was simply awful.”

 

Thursday, March 4, 2021

LEITER LOOKS BACK: FOUR PLAYS FROM 1925-1926

Bride of the Lamb.

For the latest installment of my "Leiter Looks Back" series, this one for plays from 1925-1926, please click on Theater Pizzazz.

488. SMITH. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

Don Murray, Ted Thurston, Mort Marshall.
SMITH [Musical/Fantasy/Romance/Science/Sex] B: Dean Fuller, Tony Hendra, and Matt Dubey; M/L: Matt Dubey and Dean Fuller; D: Neal Kenyon; CH: Michael Shawn; S: Fred Voelpel; C: Winn Morton; L: Martin Aronstein; P: Jordan Hott w/ Robert Anglund, Iris Kopelan, Jack Millstein, and Alexander Bedrosian; T: Eden Theatre; 5/19/73-6/3/73 (18)

Smith, which Douglas Watt dismissed as a “dud,” was a musical comedy with Pirandellian overtones about the eponymous young botanist (Don Murray) from New Jersey whose sex interests are largely confined to his research activities. This causes him to ignore the attentions of his shy, plain, female lab assistant of half-a-decade (Virginia Sandifur).

Smith would rather hire a new assistant who isn’t so solicitous. He suddenly discovers a manuscript for a musical called Smith and, before he knows what hit him, is living in the musical itself. Unable to do anything about it, he pursues the clichéd plot line. This takes him to the South Seas in search of a wonderful plant with the joint properties of inducing weight reduction and sexual arousal. In his wake is a voluptuous sexpot—the fantasy version of the drab young lab assistant he dismissed. Soon he and she are doing what he and she could never get around to back in the antiseptic laboratory days.

Brendan Gill came right out and called the show “a catastrophe,” and his thumbs-down feelings were shared by most. Watt dubbed the book “sorry” and Clive Barnes crushed the music as “forgettable.” The show’s attempt at satirizing musical of the 50s and 60s lacked life and wit, although a saving grace lay in several amusing sight gags based on the theatrical conventions of the musical in which Smith finds himself a prisoner. Star Don Murray, making his musical debut, was modestly received, but his singing abilities were deemed insufficient for a Broadway show.

Actually, the Eden Theatre, where Smith was produced, was not physically on Broadway but on Second Avenue and East Twelfth Street, although its seating capacity allowed it to operate on a Broadway contract. (When playing on an Off-Broadway contract, seats were roped off to limit the number of spectators.) The venue, which still stands, has a long history dating back to its use in the Yiddish theatre days and its subsequently serving as the home of the Phoenix Theatre at the turn of the 1960s.  In 1969 the original Oh! Calcutta! opened there. It was also a movie theatre for many years.

The musical numbers had titles like “Boy Meets Girl,” “There’s a Big Job Waiting for You,” “To the Ends of the Earth, “Onh-Honh-Honh!,” “How Beautiful It Was,” “You’re in New York Now,” and “Song of the Frog.”

Wednesday, March 3, 2021

487. SMILE, SMILE, SMILE. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

Diane J. Findlay, Casey Craig, Chip Zien, William Pierson.
SMILE, SMILE, SMILE [Musical/Fantasy/Politics] B/M/LY: Hugo Peretti, Luigi Creatore, George David Weiss; D: Robert Simpson; S: Philip Gilliam; C: Patricia McGourty; L: Barry Arnold; P: Stuart Duncan; T: Eastside Playhouse (OB); 4/4/73-4/8/73 (7)

Smile, Smile, Smile, which Douglas Watt called an “extraordinarily silly” musical, with a smidgen of a cue from Shakespeare’s The Tempest, sets its story on Paradise Island, ruled by the evil Cockalorum (Rudy Tronto). He is aided and abetted by an island spirit named Arlie (Bobby Lee), who also acts as narrator. Cockalorum has lured people of various historical periods and locales to the island, setting them to slave labor digging guano while he plies them with a will-destroying drink. A revolutionary maiden named Franny (Diane J. Findlay) ferments a rebellion and overthrows the dictator.

The production suffered from an inorganic development of character and plot, shallow characters, and borrowed ideas. Watt said it had “Insipid songs that are either desperately energetic or cravenly melodic.” But there were some decent performance, lively staging, and snappy designs, he concluded. Richard Watts disagreed about the score, dubbing it “agreeable and tuneful,” and the overall show reminiscent of Gilbert and Sullivan. Clive Barnes ended his 41-word review by noting: “It was called Smile, Smile, Smile. I didn’t, I didn’t, I didn’t.”

Song titles included "Haven't I Seen You Somewhere Before?," "Paradise," "I'm the Cockalorum," "God Bless the Fig Tree," "Love Is a Fragile Thing," "Love Is a Pain," and so forth.

Cast members who would later make a name for themselves included Chip Zien and Gary Beach.

Tuesday, March 2, 2021

486. SMALL CRAFT WARNINGS. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

Alan Mixon, Helena Carroll, David Huffman.

SMALL CRAFT WARNINGS [Drama/Alcoholism/Barroom/Homosexuality/Prostitution/Romance/ Sex] A: Tennessee Williams; D: Richard Altman; DS: Fred Voelpel; L: John Gleason; P: Ecco Productions; T: Truck and Warehouse Theatre (OB); 4/2/72-9/17/72 (200)

Brad Sullivan, Gene Fanning, William Hickey, Helena Carroll, David Hooks, 

In a seedy bar in Southern California coastal town gather an assortment of semi-derelicts: a garrulous, itinerant hairdresser named Leona Dawson (Helena Carroll); Doc (David Hooks), a drunken abortionist; Bill McCorkle (Brad Sullivan), a stud who earns his keep by his sexual prowess with both men and women; Violet (Cherry Davis, replaced by transgender icon Candy Darling), a pathetic hooker; Steve (William Hickey), her middle-aged, short-order cook boyfriend; Quentin (Alan Mixon) and Bobby (David Huffman), an overtly gay couple; and Monk (Gene Fanning), the fatherly barkeep. They talk volubly about their lives and problems, but no substantial narrative emerges.

Small Craft Warnings meanders among its characters and their self-revelations (much of it spoken as spot-lit soliloquies). “It is these sentimental tone poems that do the show in,” griped Edith Oliver. She and others found that conflict and suspense are largely absent, with the emphasis entirely on character exploration. Some, like Clive Barnes, were moved by Williams’s “enormous compassion,” the way he “opens doors into bleak and empty hearts.” As Walter Kerr expressed it, “Mr. Williams’s gift for knowing how people think, feel, and speak reasserts itself . . . enough to keep us firmly attentive.” T. E. Kalem said these people “become the embodiment of the fears that course through all of us at some time or other, the frailties that make us lie, betray any trust, cringe before bullies, vilify others—though in our hearts we wish to do none of those things.” And Henry Hewes thought the playwright’s “passionate concern for the dispossessed” was as “sublime” as ever.

But the consensus held that, touching as these people might be, the lack of dramatic tension and plot were harmful and made the play seem tiresome, verbose, and immobile. Stanley Kauffmann called it “vapid.” John Lahr put the blame on the lack of anything “to discover” about its characters, who confess all there is to know about them. Michael Smith declared that the play lacked “conviction”: “the characters seem trumped up and nudged together carelessly, and the circumstances and incidents impossible to believe.” Martin Gottfried was saddened by “one more stumble in the tragic collapse of one of the finest playwrights in theatre history,” and John Simon also mourned this “feeble self-parody . . . of his former glories.”

Small Craft Warnings originally had been titled Confessional, under which name it had was first published and produced at a workshop in Bar Harbor, Maine. During its New York run it moved to a second theatre and Williams himself appeared in it as Doc, remaining after the show during his first week to chat with the audience.