![]() |
| Song sheet from The Three Musketeers, London production. |
For the latest installment in my series, "On This Day in New York Theater," please click on THEATER LIFE.
![]() |
| Song sheet from The Three Musketeers, London production. |
For the latest installment in my series, "On This Day in New York Theater," please click on THEATER LIFE.
![]() |
| Adrienne Barbeau, Tod Miller, Stan Wiest. |
A distasteful attempt to cash in on the early 70s fad for onstage sex and nudity, Stag Movie featured
young Adrienne Barbeau before she became a TV and film star. She played a buxom
actress filming a porno musical in a motel near JFK. The plot had various silly
ingredients, including a gay actor, Mafia gangsters, and a dishonest producer.
Barbeau’s ample proportions, on frequent display, were not
sufficient distraction to keep the audience’s mind off the inane score. The
simulated sex was accompanied by songs that had “the dubious distinction of
having set the orgasm, troilism, and oral intercourse to words and music,”
smirked John Simon.
“I cannot imagine a more dispiriting and dismal evening in
the theater,” chafed Clive Barnes. “It is as appetizing and as erotic as cold
mulligawney soup laced with frozen porridge.”
Cast members included Moose Matthews (a pseudonym for a college classmate of mine who probably wishes not to be identified), Hy Anzell, Stan Wiest, and Tod Miller,
among others.
In the interest of full disclosure, I must admit that the
director, Bernard Barrow, who later played Johnny Ryan in the long-running soap
opera “Ryan’s Hope,” was my former professor and then professorial colleague and friend. The producer, Robert L. Steele, who went on to a dangerous career in
intelligence and security, was my former classmate and, for a time, teaching
colleague. Bernie and Bob: R.I.P.
![]() |
| Paul Larson, Barbara Gilbert, Diane Tarleton, Robert Elston. |
On a spare, austere, yet atmospheric set, four actors and two folk-singer guitar players effectively brought back to life Charles Aidman’s two-act adaptation of Edgar Lee Masters’s 1915 anthology of folksy poems capsulizing the townspeople of Spoon River, Illinois, at the turn of the 20th century. Its first production had been on Broadway in 1963.
Produced Off Broadway with minimal means yet maximal expressiveness, the work vividly resuscitated the town’s residents, with each actor embodying a multitude of characters. One actor from the 1963 original, Robert Elston, was back for the revival. The others were Barbara Gilbert, Paul Larson, Diane Tarleton, Lori Hillman, and Ralph Penner. “Norman Rockwell with a welcome touch of bile,” was Clive Barnes’s approving summary of this Americana program. “It wears well.”
![]() |
| Joanna Myers, Anita Keal, Randi Kallan, Edward Penn, Robin Field. |
A propagandistic, anti-drug
musical aimed at young audiences, many of whom were to be bought to the
performance through an arrangement with New York City. It presents the story of
a young, 19th-century farm family named Poppy. There is the father
(Edward Penn), the mother (Anita Keal), the child (Randi Kallan), and the dog
(Joanna Myers), the latter played by an actress with long, fur gloves and a
button nose.
The evil Smedley V.
Speed (Robert Browning) sells hard drugs to the clean-cut parents; soon they
are stoned, while the pooch must care for the child in their stead. Finally,
the now impoverished speed freaks are rescued by the efforts of traveling
salesman Thomas Jefferson Worthyman (Robin Field). They kick the habit, but
prepare for a painful withdrawal period.
The show was done as
a broad, campy spoof of Victorian melodrama, as opposed to contemporary plays
with similar themes that tried to mirror the horrors of drugs. This choice
puzzled several critics who were unsure that urban kids would respond to so
fanciful a premise for the serious message. Fortunately, the young audiences
were permitted to talk back to the actors, which enhanced their involvement.
The theme of parents being the victims was also unusual given that most such
plays concentrated on youthful abusers.
John Beaufort called
the show “coyly fatuous,” Douglas Watt thought its treatment beside the point,
and Jerry Tallmer could not sit through all of it. However, Dick Brukenfeld
liked several of its songs, and Howard Thompson called it “a pint-size charmer”
that offered “a sprightly, saucy satire of old-style, nickelodeon melodrama.”
He added that there was “infectious fun” here, with “voices ranging from good
to excellent.”
![]() |
| Company of Soon. |
A number of stellar, but as yet unrecognized, young talents were involved in this misfortune of a “rock opera,” but they could do nothing except, like the critics, hold their noses as it sank into oblivion. Its thin plot concerns a group of musicians who meet at a rock festival and go on to New York, where they hope to become successful while retaining their artistic integrity. Unfortunately, they are forced by commercial pressures to sell out artistically to a mass audience’s tastes.
Clive Barnes, who
called this offspring of Hair of “purest cornball romance,” wrote that it had a “feeble it. . .
cheap score,” a dull set of characters, and a clichéd story. Richard Watts
thought it “a rather agreeable little concoction,” though, and one or two
others found likable things in it. Still, the consensus was that Soon was “loud and empty” and couldn’t
be gone soon enough.
No director was
credited, suggesting serious production problems, Gerald Freedman’s billing noting only his “additional staging.” Soon clearly suffered from this lack of a strong helmsman. Among those who eventually
recovered from its demise and achieved varying levels of stardom were
Barry Bostwick, Marta Heflin, Richard Gere, Peter Allen, Leata Galloway, and
Nell Carter.
A sample of the song titles: ""Let the World Begin Again," "I See the Light/Gentle Sighs," "Henry is Where It's At," "Rita Cheeta," "Marketing," "To Touch the Sky," "Sweet Henry Loves You," "Doing the High," "On the Charts," and "It Won't Be Long."
For those interested
in such things, we here record that the onstage orchestra was called Pitshit.
Given the reactions to previous posts, it's likely that someone reading this will actually remember not only seeing the show (it did have 21 previews) but claim to have liked it and to be a fan.
![]() |
| Jean Bruno, Max Gulack. |
A short-lived, three-act play set in a New York Irish tavern and dealing with a conventional assortment of barroom types. It had the kind of realistic set, whispered one critic to another, that could have served as well for Saroyan’s The Time of Your Life or Gordone’s No Place to Be Somebody. Clive Barnes suggested that the set would have been better used to serve the audience drinks than to have this play acted in it.
Each character has their eccentricities, ranging
from the bartender, Norman (Max Gulack), to Gracie (Jean Bruno), an obese widow
who talks about her late husband, to Cecil (Colin Hamilton), a gay Texan whose
one-legged lover has just walked out on him (so to speak). Barnes thought the
best part was that of Momo (William Robertson), a fellow who sits in a corner
and says nothing.
The play and production
were so uninteresting that Barnes could only yawn at what he said “almost
glittered with boredom.” “Unquestionably the evening took a turn for the worse
when the actors started to talk. But they did talk—interminably, garrulously
and leisurely. The dialogue had all the sparkle of the small talk of sparrows.”
Dick Brukenfeld ranked it “less a play than a parade of red herrings.”
![]() |
| Set for Some People . . . (Photo: John Lee Beatty._ |
Self-described as “a revue with very little music,” this hapless little show was composed of thin sketches with shallow premises that lacked the substance for necessary development. Clive Barnes described the bits as one-joke ideas that exhausted their humorous potential once the joke was clear. In sum, he called it “a harmless little show” of modest pretensions.
The able, four-member cast performed a sequence of skits,
some of which were Kafkaesque in their depiction of a world where man is
threatened by the mechanical devices (phones, vacuum cleaners, tape recorders)
he needs for everyday life, or is himself metamorphosed into an inanimate
object, a spoon in one of the better scenes. (It was too early for cell phones
and personal computers.) Other routines showed such things as a man who makes
his living by drawing the arrows on maps, a clairvoyant whose future-gazing show
only the most banal things, and a scene involving two couples taking turns in
bed.
The actors were Lois Battle, Rod Browning, Jordan Crittenden,
and Carol Morley. The show is most worthy of recognition for providing only the second credited examples of leading scenic designer John Lee Beatty’s work in New York. Coincidentally, when I informed Mr. Beatty that I was going to be running this piece, he replied that, by chance, he had just come across the long-forgotten image seen at the top of this page, which he kindly allowed me to reproduce. No other production photos appear to be available. His note mentioned that a newspaper strike at the time of the opening prevented the bad reviews from coming out. "Once they did, we closed immediately!"