Friday, March 26, 2021

511. SUNDAY DINNER. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

Martin Shakar, Lois Smith, Brooks Morton, Jerome Dempsey, Jacqueline Brookes, Patrick Mcvey (seated). (Photo: Martha Holmes.)
SUNDAY DINNER [Drama/Family] A: Joyce Carol Oates; D: Curt Dempster; S: Kurt Lundell; C: Willa Kim; L: Roger Morgan; P: American Place Theatre; T: St. Clement’s Church (OB); 10/16/70-11/25/70 (41)

A Midwestern family sits down to its Sunday ritual of eating dinner after visiting the grave of their late matriarch. A strange, blind census taker (Patrick McVey) intrudes upon the scene and gradually makes each squirm as their personal guilt is drawn out. Eventually, he is ejected (although he may well be their long absent father), and his place is taken by one of the sons.

This play by prolific novelist Joyce Carol Oates was turned down by all the critics. As Richard Watts phrased it, Sunday Dinner was pretentious, studiously obscure, and ponderous.” Few were able to grasp the author’s point, and most felt there was nothing but a vacuum at its core. Clive Barnes thought it an allegory of sorts with murky, symbolic trappings. Walter Kerr was put off by its qualities of self-indulgence. Martin Gottfried knocked it for being “awkwardly and insincerely written” in the vein of Harold Pinter.

Few quarrels were picked with the acting or directing. As John Simon noted, they “seem to know how it is done even if they don’t know what it is they are doing.”

The rather distinguished cast included Jacqueline Brookes, Lois Smith, Brooks Morton, Jerome Dempsey, and Martin Shakar.

Next up: Sunset

Thursday, March 25, 2021

510. SUMMERFOLK. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

Estelle Kohler, Ian Richardson, Mike Gwilym, Janet Whiteside, Susan Fleetwood.
SUMMERFOLK [Comedy-Drama/Marriage/Politics/Romance/Russia/Russian] A: Maxim Gorky; TR: Jeremy Brooks and Kitty Hunter Blair; D: David Jones; DS: Timothy O’Brien, Tazeena Firth; L: Stewart Leviton; M: Carl Davis; P: Brooklyn Academy of Music b/a/w the Royal Shakespeare Theatre, Stratford-Upon-Avon, in the Royal Shakespeare Company Production; T: Brooklyn Academy of Music (OB); 2/5/75-4/6/75 (13)

England’s RSC appeared in New York frequently in the 70s, usually at the Brooklyn Academy of Music, with plays both new and old. In the present instance they were represented by a 1904 Gorky play, but one that was new to New York, so it wasn’t a true revival.

Gorky’s Enemies had sparked much admiration when given its New York premiere earlier in the decade. His Summerfolk demonstrated even more cogently the playwright’s long-neglected talents, best known mainly for The Lower Depths.

Character, rather than plot, predominates in this sensitively evocative picture of a cross-section of successful members of the Russian bourgeoisie—the descendants of peasants, not, as in Chekhov, the gentry—at the turn of the 20th century. These folk come from the city every summer to their riverside dachas, and return to the city in the fall. In this countryside setting, Gorky introduces his many summerfolk. With great skill, he realizes them three-dimensionally both as creatures to be scorned and people to be savored. They represent a class doomed by the corruption represented by their idle lives, a class soon to be swept away by the tidal wave of the Russian Revolution. Although Gorky’s political viewpoint clearly is on the side of the toiling masses, he offers these apathetic beings full opportunity to defend their way of life.

The three-and-a-half hour drama, which was superbly staged and acted, takes place in in the environs of a dacha owned by Bassov (Norman Rodway), a lawyer, who is married to the Nora Helmer-like Varvara (Estelle Kohler). Their friends and relations, who pass the time in gossip, love-making, quarreling, and adultery, include familiar figures reminiscent of Chekhov’s: a jaded novelist, Shalimov (Ian Richardson); Bassov’s poet-sister, Kaleria Vassilievna (Susan Fleetwood); an engineer, Suslov (Tony Church); his wife, Yulia Filipovna (Lynette Davies); her lover, Zamislov (David Suchet); Suslov’s tycoon uncle, Dvoetochie (Sebastian Shaw); a widowed female doctor, Maria Lvovna (Margaret Tyzack); Varvara’s clownish brother, Vlass Mikhailich (Mike Gwilym), and a host of others.

John Simon reveled in what he called a “wonder” of an event in which “the lofty ideas of a playwright are given magnificent embodiment in a remarkable production” of a “rarer-than-rare play.” “Here Gorky . . . has an exquisite sense of atmosphere, of a social and psychological climate conveyed neither through an unusual plot nor through a significant change in a principal character . . . , but through the subtle yet volatile interaction of a very considerable number of persons used like instruments in a concerto grosso,” he added.

Calling it a sequel to Chekhov’s The Cherry Orchard, Clive Barnes loved the play’s blend of “philosophy, humor and honesty,” calling it “marvelous,” a word also used by Douglas Watt, who forgave its “blunt, meandering and derivative” style because it was so ‘brimming with vitality” in both the writing and performances. “The cumulative effect . . . is quite powerful,” noted Edwin Wilson, who was never once bored during the lengthy performance, and who wished he could continue to live with Gorky’s people.

There was universal acclamation for what Simon deemed the “almost flawlessly unified performing” of the ensemble, although Estelle Kohler’s exquisite portrait of the disillusioned Varvara gathered the greatest attention. David Jones’s reputation as a director of Gorky was immeasurably enhanced, and the set and costume designs of O’Brien and Firth added enormously to the work’s quality.

The Royal Shakespeare Company was rewarded with an OBIE Special Citation for its contribution, produced in repertory with Love’s Labour’s Lost.

 

 

Wednesday, March 24, 2021

509. SUGGS. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

William Atherton.

SUGGS [Comedy] A: David Wiltse; D: Dan Sullivan; S: Douglas W. Schmidt; C: Jeanne Button; L: John Gleason; P: Repertory Theatre of Lincoln Center; T: Forum Theatre (OB); 5/4/72-5/20/72 (20)

Lee Lawson, William Atherton.

“[T]he erosion of innocence,” as Edith Oliver put it, was the subject of David Wiltse’s well-liked piece that, unfortunately, was given only a limited run of 20 showings.

A cheerful, optimistic young Kansan, George Suggs (William Atherton), arrives in the Big Apple to pursue a career as a broadcast sports announcer. He begins his New York life with the rosiest of attitudes, but gradually finds his initial good will crumbling under an onslaught of the city’s ills. Many of his frustrations are forthrightly delivered in direct address.

Robert Levine, Lee Lawson, Joan Pape.

Conventional in its sideswiping blows at the hassles of urban survival, an existence “overrun by derelicts, drug addicts, panhandlers, muggers, prostitutes, depressed and case-hardened employers, dissatisfied wives, [and] crooks,” in Harold Clurman’s words, Suggs remained “engagingly ironic, swift in pace, [and] happily devoid of portentousness.” Henry Hewes thought it was “neatly crafted, highly entertaining.”

Ralph Bell, William Atherton.

William Atherton, “always seemingly unaware of what is happening to him as his jauntiness and trust slowly ebb away, gives a first-rate comic performance,” wrote Oliver.

David Wiltse won a Drama Desk Award for Most Promising Playwright, and Drama Desk Awards also went to William Atherton and director Dan Sullivan, then at the outset of his prolific career. Atherton also snared a Theatre World Award.

Next up: Summerfolk

Tuesday, March 23, 2021

508. "SUGAR-MOUTH SAM DON'T DANCE NO MORE" and "ORRIN." From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

“SUGAR-MOUTH SAM DON’T DANCE NO MORE” and “ORRIN” [Drama/Drugs/Family/One-Acts/Race/Romance] A: Don Evans; D: Helaine Head; P: Negro Ensemble Company; T: St. Marks Playhouse (OB); 5/6/75-5/11/75 (8)

Note: No photos of this production are available.

This pair of one-acts was produced by the Negro Ensemble Company as part of their month-long 1975 “Season-Within-a-Season” festival of workshop productions. They were “small and predictable,” wrote Mel Gussow, but had “a sharpness in the writing, embellished by the performances.”

Both plays had prodigal characters attempting to make homecomings. The title character in “Orrin” (Taurean Blacque), a drug dealer/junkie, was kicked out of his middle-class Philadelphia home by his moralistic dad (Carl Gordon). He returns uninvited eight months later, his presence proving disruptive.

Sam (also Carl Gordon) in “Sugar-Mouth Sam Don’t Dance No More” has been having an erratic love affair with Verda Mae Hollis (Lea Scott) for years. He returns to her place yet one more time to rekindle the flame before he again departs, Tired of his infidelity, Verda Mae's sense of womanly independence emerges.

Like Gussow, Edith Oliver saw value in these short plays, especially in their character depiction.

Next up: Suggs

Monday, March 22, 2021

507. SUGAR. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 197O-1975


Sheila Smith (left, with baton), Tony Roberts, Robert Morse, and company
SUGAR [Musical/Crime/Period/Romance/Show Business] B: Peter Stone; M: Jule Styne; LY: Bob Merrill; SC: Billy Wilder and I.A.L. Diamond’s screenplay, Some Like it Hot (from a Robert Thornton story); D/CH: Gower Champion; S: Robin Wagner; C: Alvin Colt; L: Martin Aronstein; P: David Merrick; T: Majestic Theatre; 4/9/72-6/23/73 (515)

Cyril Ritchard, Tony Roberts.

A musical version of Some Like It Hot, the ever-popular, crossdressing, 1959 film farce, set in the Roaring Twenties, in which Elaine Joyce, Tony Roberts, and Robert Morse took the roles immortalized on screen by Marilyn Monroe, Tony Curtis, and Jack Lemmon. It came into New York after expensive out-of-town revisions, including the replacement of the book writer, as well as of both the set designer and his set. Cast changes and production doctoring were other remedies applied to the ailing show. 

Robert Morse, Tony Roberts, Sheila Smith (right)

For all its troubles, the show had a fairly robust run while failing to satisfy many critics. For most, it was an elaborate, colorful show of what Julius Novick deemed “deeply mediocre” quality. It was, he added, “smooth, polished, professional, safe, and not very interesting.” “It doesn’t work as a musical,” claimed Clive Barnes, who, like various others, thought its performances the chief reason for a visit. Sugar, he remarked, “Had a dearth of jokes, a shortage of wit and a scarcity of verbal humor that is almost remarkable.” John Simon, on the other hand, believed its many weaknesses were made up for by its being “the most diverting, stylishly mounted, smoothly acted, brilliantly staged and endearingly danced [non-musical musical] in many a season.”

Composer Jule Styne and lyricist Bob Merrill, both Broadway A-listers, were accorded little but condescension for what Brendan Gill labeled their “workmanlike and old-fashioned” score, Walter Kerr, however, found pleasure in the music’s authentic period sound and in the energetic title song. The other numbers were “Windy City Marmalade,” “Penniless Bums,” “Tear the Town Apart,” “The Beauty that Drives Men Mad,” “We Could Be Close,” “Sun on My Face,” “November Song,” “Hey, Why Not!,” “Beautiful Through and Through,” “What Do You Give to a Man Who’s Had Everything?,” “Magic Nights,” “It’s Always Love,” and “When You Meet a Man in Chicago.”

Robert Morse, Elaine Joyce.
The familiar plot tells of two jobless Chicago musicians, Jerry (Morse) and Joe (Roberts), who are on the lam after witnessing the infamous St. Valentine’s Day Massacre. They disguise themselves as performers in an all-girl band, where each falls for singer Sugar Kane (Joyce), a simpleminded blonde with her heart set on marrying a millionaire. In the course of the action, a rich old lech (Cyril Ritchard, Joe. E. Brown in the movie) pursues Jerry, thinking him female, of course, with intentions of marriage. Ultimately, the pursuing gangsters are disposed of and Joe gets Sugar.

The attractive Elaine Joyce and the appealing Tony Roberts were sweetly but not very enthusiastically received. Robert Morse’s performance, despite being slapped for too much mugging, was the big attraction, especially for a hilarious scene in which Ritchard tried ardently to seduce him. 

Master showman Gower Champion’s work, which inspired Simon to comment that it “was one of the few consummate pieces of musical staging I have witnessed,” demonstrated great inventiveness in many routines, like the staccato tap dance performed by chief gangster Spats Palazzo (Steve Condos). On the other hand, it was noted that Champion offered insufficient musical staging for the singing numbers. T.E. Kalem, unimpressed, thought “the dances could be inserted in another musical, where they would mean no more and no less than they do in Sugar.”

Despite bland notices, Sugar entertained audiences for over 500 performances. It received Tony nominations for Best Musical; Best Director, Musical; Best Choreographer; and, for Morse, Best Actor, Musical. Elaine Joyce won a Theatre World Award.

Next up: Sugar Mouth Sam Don’t Dance No More and Orrin


Sunday, March 21, 2021

506. SUBJECT TO FITS. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

James DeMarse, Sharon Laughlin, Andy Robinson. (Photos: Zodiac,)

SUBJECT TO FITS [Drama/Mental Illness/Period/Russia] A/M: Robert Montgomery; SC: Dostoievsky’s novel, The Idiot; D: A.J. Antoon; S: Leo Yoshimura; C: Theoni V. Aldredge; L: Ian Calderon; P: New York Shakespeare Festival/Other Stage/Florence S. Anspacher Theatre (OB); 2/14/71-5/30/71 (127)

Katharine Dunfee, John Glover.

Robert Montgomery was a third-year Yale Drama School student when his play, Subject to Fits, based on a classic 19th-century Russian novel by Fyodor Dostoievsky, was produced in New York. Robert Brustein, then Dean of the Drama School, had seen a workshop staging and turned it down as a possibility for his own Yale Repertory Company. The director, fellow Yalie A.J. Antoon, soon became a Public Theatre stalwart.

Andy Robinson, Jason Miller.

Montgomery’s program notes said this was drama “smacking of The Idiot, dreaming of The Idiot, but mostly taking off from where The Idiot drove it.” The play suggested a style of “realistic surrealism,” wrote Martin Gottfried, in its fragmented, episodic structure and bizarre characters, at the center of which is the Christ-like Prince Myshkin (Andy Robinson). Instead of a straightforward plot, Montgomery offered what Stanley Kauffmann called “states of being,” his purpose being to “put Dostoievsky’s theme through the mind of a young Christian today, to trace the question of possible good, expressing through the fact of the songs and distortions, the modernity of his inquiry.”

Characters retained from the novel include Rogozhin (Jason Miller, later to write That Championship Season; succeeded by John Glover), anything but a saint; Natasha (Sharon Laughlin), the temptress; Lebedev (John Mahon), Aglaya (Katherine Dunfee), and Madame Yepanchin (Jean David), among several others.

Andy Robinson (in box) and company.

Because of the lack of conventional narrative material, several reviewers were convinced the theatregoer would be confused unless he had a close familiarity with the novel. Walter Kerr, for instance, found only the brilliance of Antoon’s staging and the excellence of Montgomery’s music strong enough elements to hold him in his seat. Though the skull-teasing script was “tantalizing . . . , provocative and strongly self-possessed,” he warned, “casual theatregoers beware.” Also less than inspired was Edith Oliver, for whom the show was “theatrical without being especially dramatic—a kind of ballet with words that is intermittently interesting for about one quarter of its two acts.”

On the other hand, a passel of critics, led by Clive Barnes, were excited over the play. Barnes sang his praises for this “mad, mad play that is a joy to encounter. It is a cerebral play of dazzling intellectuality, manic wit, and calm literacy.” Reviews like this may have helped Montgomery win a Drama Desk Award for Most Promising Playwright.

My frequent plus-one of pre-Covid days, Ken Glickfeld, one of the best cue-callers in the business, was the stage manager.

Dostoevsky lovers (or even Dostoyevsky ones) might, if they are masochistic enough, wish to peruse my comments on a 2016 adaptation of the play, with the simplified title of Idiot. 

Next up: Sugar

 

Saturday, March 20, 2021

505. THE STY OF THE BLIND PIG. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975


Frances Foster, Moses Gunn.
THE STY OF THE BLIND PIG [Drama/Family/Race/Religion/Romance] A: Philip Hayes Dean; D: Shauneille Perry; S: Edward Burbridge; C: Steve Carter; L: Ernest Baxter; P: Negro Ensemble Company; T: St. Marks Playhouse (OB): 11/16/71-1/9/72 (64)
Frances Foster, Moses Gunn.

The critics hedged in their acceptance of this rather enigmatic naturalist-symbolist drama, set in a Chicago ghetto apartment during the mid-50s just prior to the explosion of the Civil Rights movement. “To an extent,” noted Clive Barnes, “it lacks that special element of drama, that quality of surprise, that quick response of the imagination. . . . And yet the work nags with its truth.” “[A] talented . . . but unsatisfactory play,” added Walter Kerr. And Julius Novick remarked, “the play . . . , though not devoid of integrity and even a measure of distinction, is . . . somewhat less than admirable.”

Blind Jordan (Moses Gunn), a sightless street singer, born in a whorehouse (“a blind pig”), comes to the door of a white family’s domestic. She is 30-year-old Alberta (Frances Foster), who lives with her churchgoing, stodgy, possessive, whisky-tippling mother, Weedy (Clarice Taylor). Jordan is searching for a lost love named Grace. Also present is a numbers-running uncle, Doc (Adolph Caesar).

Jordan is persuaded by the lonely, love-starved Alberta to stay with her, although Weedy resents him. When Weedy departs for a religious meeting in Montgomery, Alabama, Jordan leaves as well—at Alberta’s request—but soon returns. Weedy comes home amazed and disturbed at the new spirit of defiance—black women refusing to ride in the back of the bus!—she observed down South. The mysterious singer is persuaded by Weedy to depart and Alberta’s behavior begins to resemble that of her complacent, old-fashioned mother.

Clarice Taylor, Adolph Caesar.

The theme of black complacency in the face of shifting social and racial attitudes was insufficiently explored, thought some. Excessive dialogue and length, shallow character development, obscure plotting, and lack of variety were cited. However, Martin Gottfried was so moved he called the work “one of the most artistically conceived and best-written . . . I have seen in a long time.” And T.E. Kalem joined in, feeling that “this consecrated act of theatre was eloquent, powerful, moving and beautiful.” Also reaping positive feedback were the set, the direction, and the ensemble. 

Playwright Dean won a Drama Desk Award for Most Promising Playwright, as well as the Elizabeth Hull—Kate Warriner Award. A TV adaptation appeared in 1974. 

Next up: Subject to Fits