Saturday, June 13, 2020

154. AN ENEMY OF THE PEOPLE. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 19701975

Conrad Bain, James Blendick, Stephen Elliott, David Birney, Philip Bosco.

AN ENEMY OF THE PEOPLE [Dramatic Revival] A: Henrik Ibsen; AD: Arthur Miller; D: Jules Irving; S: Douglas W. Schmidt; C: Carrie F. Robbins; L: John Gleason; P: Repertory Theatre of Lincoln Center; T: Vivian Beaumont Theatre; 3/11/71-4/25/72 (54)

Don Plumley, Stephen Elliott, Barbara Cason, James Blendick, David Birney, Tandy Cronin.
Arthur Miller’s 1950 version of Ibsen’s 1882 play, in which the theme of majority rule opposed by minority beliefs is central, received mixed reactions in this Lincoln Center revival. Apart from Walter Kerr’s pan, Stephen Elliott drew strong praise for his portrayal of Dr. Stockman. He, of course, is the noble scientist who wishes to make public his discovery that the town’s popular health baths are polluted, thereby creating a public uproar when the townspeople, seeing their livelihoods affected, turn against him.

Stephen Elliott, Philip Bosco.
In Jack Kroll’s opinion, Miller’s adaptation scaled “down Ibsen’s complex and disturbing power to liberal moralizing.” Others, like Brendan Gill, censured the “ugly” use of language and the dated 1950ish slang that made the work seem more outmoded in 1971 than William Archer’s Victorian translation. The play seemed “silly” to Kerr, particularly in what he deemed a poor production. And Martin Gottfried claimed the fairly regularly revived play, which (as always) some believed pertinent to contemporary political and ecological concerns, had no true “lasting value” and was too “message” oriented. He scored the acting and direction, as well as the general drabness that made it seem “an economy production all around.”

Barbara Cason, Stephen Elliott, Tandy Cronin, and company.
 Among the several favorable notices was that of Harold Clurman, who called it “sound and immensely effective.” The cast included such well-known names as Sydney Walker, David Birney, Philip Bosco, Tandy Cronin, and Conrad Bain.