Friday, July 3, 2020

197. GHOSTS (2 PRODUCTIONS). From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

Wesley Addy, Victor Garber, Beatrice Straight.
1.
GHOSTS [Dramatic Revival] A: Henrik Ibsen; AD/D: Gene Feist; S: Holmes Easley; C: Sue A. Robbins; L: R.S. Winkler; M: Philip Campanella; P: Roundabout Theatre Company; T: Roundabout Theatre (OB); 3/13/73-5/27/73 (89)

Ibsen’s once controversial 1882 masterpiece about the blind adherence to convention was acceptably, if unmemorably, performed in this Roundabout version starring noteworthy thespians Beatrice Straight as Mrs. Alving and Wesley Addy as Pastor Manders, with Victor Garber making his New York debut as Osvald. Staged in the three-quarters round in the company’s cramped basement venue, the production had an intimacy and “claustrophobic attitude” that served the play well, according to Clive Barnes.

Most of the reviewers were glad to see Ghosts revived, but Martin Gottfried disdained the drama as “dumb, dumb, dumb as only Ibsen, Ibsen can be.” He called the staging “only semiprofessional,” laughed scornfully at Addy as a “silver-haired, beautifully profiled, Barrymore ham,” saw interesting things in Victor Garber’s Osvald, and felt Straight did what she could with a thankless role.

Nevertheless, most of the other reviews leaned positive. Douglas Watt did pass on it as “competent, but rather bland,” seeing little chemistry between Alving and Manders, but Barnes thought the production “more than decent,” and considered the entire company strong, “with a lovely, tender and very restrained performance” from Straight. Garber received a Theatre World Award for his efforts.

2.
TR: Rolfe Fjelde; D: Leonard Shapiro; DS: Jerry Rojo; C: Theodore Skipitares; P: New York Shakespeare Festival; T: Public Theater/Little Theater (OB); 3/6/75-5/18/75 (37)

(No photos available)

The second Ghosts revival of the early 1970s used an environmental approach, which was prevalent in avant-garde theatre of the period, for this hotly debated interpretation. It was a product of the Shaliko troupe, based at New York University, which Joe Papp’s Public Theater offered a guest residency for a repertory of Ibsen’s play and Brecht’s The Measures Taken. The set was created by master environmentalist, Jerry Rojo, but the production was scoffed at by the major critics. Edith Oliver, for example, thought that neither director Leonard Shapiro nor designer Rojo had done “a thing for Ibsen.”

The seating was scattered all around the set in an arrangement that cut off some parts of the acting area, making it difficult for everyone to see everything. The environment represented a 19th-century house, cluttered with “a tasteless array of decorator-style Victorian bric-a-bric,” according to Clive Barnes. The players acted over, under, and around the audience. Walter Kerr had to quickly pull back his feet when Regina (Jane Mandel), the maid, began to water a plant whose leaves lapped over his toes.

The interpretation, which Kerr likened to “a Kung Fu version of Ibsen’s play,” was a freewheeling one using as many unconventional tricks and devices as possible. Barnes likened the result of the energetic performance to “Grotowski-inspired chaos” that travestied the drama. He wrote that the production had no specific “tone” or “sensibility toward the play,” and described the acting as “ranting, screaming, ogling, mugging, whining and general misbehaving.”

Mrs. Alving was played by Mary Zakrzewski as a sex-starved, heavy-drinking slattern who, at one point, “makes a headlong dive at Manders [Tom Crawley] . . . and kisses him with such cobra-like passion, slithering the while, that he feels himself compelled to hurl her to the floor,” sneered Kerr. All in all, this was, he concluded, a “thoroughly mindless” revival.