Saturday, January 30, 2021

456. THE SCHOOL FOR WIVES. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.


Brian Bedford, Joan Van Ark.
THE SCHOOL FOR WIVES [Dramatic Revival] A: Molière; TR: Richard Wilbur; D: Stephen Porter; S/L: James Tilton; C: Nancy Potts; M: Conrad Susa; P: Phoenix Theatre; T: Lyceum Theatre; 2/16/71-5/29/71 (120)

Never before produced on Broadway in English, Molière’s L’École des Femmes was provided with an outstanding production under Stephen Porter’s clever directorial guidance. Brian Bedford received accolades for his inimitable performance as Arnolphe, an aging and jealous gentleman married to Agnes (Joan Van Ark). She is the sweet young thing he wishes to protect from younger suitors by shielding her from their gaze.

David Dukes, Brian Bedford, Peggy Pope, James Greene, Joan Van Ark.

The complications that ensue when his friend, the dashing young Horace (David Dukes) falls in love with and tries to woo Agnes, without knowing her relationship to Arnolphe, offer the basis for this comedy of cuckoldry.

Translator Richard Wilbur’s sprightly rhymed couplets, said the delighted Richard Watts, roll “off the tongue with such idiomatic ease that is [sic] sounds for all the world like an English classic.” Most observers thought the humor and charm were on a par with the best Broadway entertainment, considering the company mettlesome, and the direction warm, zestful, and human. A rare detractor was Brendan Gill, who deemed this a “conscientious” but essentially joyless revival. Despite valiant efforts, he observed, “the play has slipped through their over-careful fingers.” Commenting on the title, he stated that it should be translated without the definite article.

James Greene, Brian Bedford, Peggy Pope.

Bedford, an admired English actor who often starred on Broadway in British plays (especially the classics), was, to many, the show’s best feature. Douglas Watt felt he gave “a smashing comedy performance” in which he “seizes the part and plays it as the young Charles Laughton might have done, but in his own special style. His rages are heartfelt and passionately presented. . . . It is a sweeping, majestic comic performance that often succeeds in arousing our sympathy for this superior fellow whose ill luck it is to be confounded by ninnies.” To T.E. Kalem Bedford was “a comic marvel. His face is an ever-changing panorama of unholy glee, bottomless despair, and a sour-pickle sneer.” Among the few sourly sneering responses, however, was that of Stanley Kauffmann, who found Bedford mannered and unconvincing.

George Pentecost, Brian Bedford.

Barnes added, "The two other leading actors, the flourishing Horace of David Dukes and the radiantly innocent Agnes of Joan van [sic] Ark, show just the right panache, also giving the play the verve and sparkle it demands."

Bedford walked off with the Tony for Best Actor, Play, and the Drama Desk Award for Outstanding Performance. Van Ark received a Tony nomination for Best Supporting Actress, Play, and a Theatre World Award.