Thursday, February 4, 2021

461. THE SEAGULL (2 productions). From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.


Roundabout Company recreating a famous photo of the Moscow Art Theatre being read the script of The Seagull by Anton Chekhov, with director Gene Feist (up center) as Chekhov.
 1.

THE SEAGULL [Dramatic Revival] A: Anton Chekhov; AD/D: Gene Feist; S: Holmes Easley; C: Mimi Maxmen; L: John McClain; M: Philip Campanella; P: Roundabout Theatre Company; T: Roundabout Theatre (OB); 12/18/73-3/17/74 (105)

Delores Sutton, Tom Klunis.

This revival of Chekhov’s 1898 comedy-drama--one of several in the same time frame--coincided with the 75th anniversary of its original Moscow Art Theatre production. Roundabout Theatre’s founder, Gene Feist, directed it in his intimate arena theatre to an only moderately receptive press. Clive Barnes termed it a demonstration rather than an illumination of the text.

Chekhov’s complex, symbol-laden, atmospheric look at the lives of a frustrated would-be writer, Konstantin (Christopher Lloyd), his exuberantly theatrical mother, Arkadina (Delores Sutton), Arkadina’s novelist lover, Trigorin (Tom Klunis), and the object of both Konstantin and Trigorin’s affections, Nina (Linda De Coff), was staged with little interpretive originality. This led to what Barnes dismissed as a fairly “bland” presentation, despite a “good and exceptionally well-balanced” cast.

Walter Kerr, however, considered this a “generally interesting revival” in which he noticed how deliberately time passed without the clutter of the kind minutia often inserted to provide the play with a patina of naturalism. He and Barnes responded positively to Sutton’s Arkadina, but they had less respect for Klunis’s Trigorin. The Konstantin of Lloyd, gradually coming into his own as an important character actor, was “particularly impressive.”

Others on hand included Paula Laurence as Polina, Laura Esterman as Masha, and Robert Stattel as Medvedenko.

2.

D: Andre Gregory; S: Ming Cho Lee; C: Nanzi Adzima; L: Victor En Yu Tan; P: Lyn Austin i/a/w the New York Shakespeare Festival; T: Public Theater, Martinson Hall (OB); 1/8/75-4/5/75 (42)

Note: no photo is immediately available for this production.

Experimental director Andre Gregory, who called his revival simply Sea Gull, staged it with his Manhattan Project company at the Public, where Joseph Papp supported it along with a company staging of Wallace Shawn’s Our Late Night. (Gregory and Shawn have shared a long history as collaborators.) 

The production moved Chekhov to the 1930s, incorporated such background music as “St. Louis Blues,” and used the device of a semi-environmental design in which the action was spread over three acting areas, to each of which the audience moved en masse when a new act began. 

The approach sought to scoop out the meanings and textures between the author’s lines by means of surprising gestures, behavior, and line readings. All of it was done in a very subdued, practically whispered manner, creating an effect of subtext, rather than the play proper, being performed.

The major weakness, averred Clive Barnes, was the “lack of cultural resonance and an avoidance of theatrical tradition.” He nevertheless found the evening worthwhile as a new approach to a classic. Walter Kerr, however, was dismayed at the inaudibility of the actors, and the monotony of the style. John Simon abandoned ship after one act because of what he deemed the inadequacy of this “troupe . . . most of whom are consummate nonentities in both talent and appearance.” 

Among the "nonentities" were Saskia Noordhoek Hegt as Arkadina, Larry Pine as Constantine, Angela Pietropinto as Nina, and Gerry Bamman as Trigorin.

There were two other, barely noticed, minor productions of The Seagull during the 1974-1975 season, one at the Cubiculo, directed by Philip Meister, which opened on December 11, 1974, for 11 performances. The other was directed by Joseph Chaikin for the Manhattan Theatre Club, opening on January 21, 1975, and compiling 24 performances. Leueen McGrath was Arkadina, Bernard Duffy was Konstantine, and Tina Shepard was Nina. 


Wednesday, February 3, 2021

460. THE SEA HORSE. From my ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

Edward J. Moore, Conchatta Farrell.

THE SEA HORSE [Comedy-Drama/Barroom/Romance/Two Characters] A: James Irwin [Edward J. Moore]; D: Marshall W. Mason; S: David Potts; C: Jennifer von Mayrhauser; L: Cheryl Thacker; P: Circle Repertory Company; T: Westside Theatre (OB); 4/15/74-8/4/74 (128)

Conchetta Farrell, Edward J. Moore.

This much admired play, produced by the Circle Rep, was the third in little more than a year to be transferred from an Off-Off to an Off-Broadway mounting. Author Edward J. Moore, who played Harry Bales, at first used the penname of James Irwin. He had his authorial billing changed only when, after the play’s successful Off-Broadway opening, the press learned of his contribution.

The Sea Horse was a perfect match for the deft naturalism in which Circle actors and their director, Marshall W. Mason, specialized. It was performed within a thoroughly realistic set of a West Coast waterfront saloon, the Sea Horse, presided over by the fat, feisty, but distrustful Gertrude Blum (Conchatta Ferrell). The only other character an employee named Harry Bales, who loves both fixing things and Gertrude Blum.

The action centers on his attempts to break down the independent-minded Gertrude’s defenses, and get her to acknowledge her affection for him so they can get married. He uses all the ploys at his disposal, especially humor, to expose her vulnerability. By the play’s end, a rapprochement seems entirely possible.

Moore succeeded in making his characters seem alive and interesting, and the acting and direction were perfectly complimentary to the dramatic needs. The major problems were said to include the overuse of naval machinery sound effects imitated by Harry as he describes them, and too artificial a recounting by Gertrude of her unhappy life’s experiences. The remainder, however, was “honest and intelligent in most ways, and the dialogue abounds in comic as well as serious felicities,” wrote John Simon. Walter Kerr, though, argued that the play, “briskly written and cagily acted,” was marred by “a strong sense of arbitrariness, a calculated rise and fall of temperature.”

Ferrell won an OBIE for Distinguished Performance, as well as a Theatre World Award and a Drama Desk Award. Moore was also honored by the Drama Desk, as Outstanding New Playwright.

 

Tuesday, February 2, 2021

459. THE SCREENS. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.



Joseph Della Sorte, Osceola Archer, Robert Jackson. (Photos: Alan B. Tepper)
THE SCREENS [Comedy-Drama/French/Military/Politics] A: Jean Genet; TR: Bernard Frechtman; D: Minos Volanakis; S: Robert Mitchell; C: Willa Kim; L: Bennett Averyt; P: Chelsea Theatre Center of Brooklyn; T: Chelsea Theatre, Brooklyn Academy of Music (OB); 11/30/71 (28)

Grayson Hall.

The Chelsea Theatre’s monumental staging of this controversial four-and-a-half hour, 17-scene epic drama about characters embroiled in the Algerian war of independence against France was one of the theatrical landmarks of the early 70s. It was written in 1959, published in 1961, and first staged in Paris by Jean-Louis Barrault in 1966, after five years of being officially barred from production. Barrault’s staging led to riots by those who claimed it to be an anti-French depiction of the strife.

Genet’s nihilistic black farce was more than just anti-French. It was anti “all of modern civilization,” noted Harold Clurman, being an attack on the conventional morality of goodness and decency and a paean to evil, “a celebration of the elegance of vice,” as John Simon phrased it. During its nonlinear, episodic, fragilely constructed plot, Genet shoots scorching satiric fireballs at the decadence and corruption of French imperialism, at the pederasty of the French army troops, and at multiple other targets.

The surrealistic tale is told with dynamic and poetically charged language, often profoundly scatological, with a barrage of theatrical inventiveness carried out by a company of over 40 actors handling more than 80 roles.

The Europeans.

The Screens, called by Clive Barnes “an elongated strip cartoon of a civilization in the process of death,” tells of the oppressed young Algerian farmhand Said (Robert Jackson), a poverty-stricken misfit so poor he must obtain money by wedding Leila (Janet League), an ugly, foul-smelling girl, thus relieving her father of her. He is guided in his actions by his equally repulsive mother (Julie Bovasso). Said treats Leila with sadistic contempt, turns for sex to whores, and sinks ever lower into a life of thievery, which continually sends him to prison. Leila, who responds ecstatically to Said’s sadism, is his willing partner in crime. In his perverted desire to achieve transcendent guilt, Said betrays his nation to the French, and eventually is slain by the Algerians.

The Revolutionaries.

What Simon dubbed an “endless, sticky, mazy, maddening marathon of a play” moved effortlessly through its many scenes via the use of 10-foot high screens that set the locales, disbursing the actors on the floor and on platforms of varying levels situated before a long wall in the rectangular space, with the audience facing the action on tiers of bleachers. Clurman suggested that these titular screens were also “symbols of the false front behind which we hide our villainies.”

Although most critics were intoxicated by the sheer scope of this “tidal wave of total theatre,” in Jack Kroll’s words, there were those, like T.E. Kalem, for whom it more closely resembled “a roiling, debris-clotted river in flood.” Kalem saw “the flaw . . . in the script’s grandiose pretensions, which dwarf interest in any individual.” Barnes noted the difficulty of sustaining concentration on this rambling work: “its picturesque wanderings at first amuse and then rather annoy.” Walter Kerr said, “If there were a thousand ways of expressing any given thought, Genet has here used all of them at once.”

The great majority felt that director Minos Volanakis had created what Kroll called an “amazing” production, one that was helped enormously by Willa Kim’s costumes and Robert Mitchell’s sets. Clurman was awed by the director’s “fidelity and understanding of the script” in which every nuance and intention was made clear and “theatrically visualized.” However, Michael Smith thought the work “earthbound.” The acting was not particularly inspired, but Julie Bovasso as the Mother and Despo as Kadidja were superlative.

The huge company included Grayson Hall, Marilyn Chris, Barry Bostwick (!), Sasha von Scherler, Marilyn Sokol.

Several honors recognized this show’s achievements, among them the New York Drama Critics Circle Award for Best Foreign Play. Willa Kim’s costume designs won the Maharam Foundation award, the Drama Desk Award, and Variety’s Off-Broadway poll for Best Costume Design.

Monday, February 1, 2021

458. SCRATCH. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.

Will Mackenzie, Will Geer, Patrick Magee.
SCRATCH [Drama/Fantasy/Period/Political/Trial] A: Archibald MacLeish; SC: Steven Vincent Benet’s short story, “The Devil and Daniel Webster”; D: Peter H. Hunt; S: John Conklin; C: Patricia Zipprodt; L: Feder; P: Stuart Ostrow; T: St. James Theatre; 5/6/71-5/8/71 (4)

Will Geer, Patrick Magee.
Archibald MacLeish, distinguished poet, playwright, teacher, and statesman, was 79 when he wrote this, his last Broadway play (he was best known for J.B.). He had intended it as a drama in which the historical character of statesman Daniel Webster would be put on trial, in the playwright’s view, for having sold his soul in 1850 by agreeing to support a policy that would favor Southern slave owners (although he was a professed abolitionist) while managing to prevent dissolution of the Union for at least another decade. Thus, the relation of morality to politics was a chief concern. (Perhaps some present-day playwright might consider updating the tale to our current political situation.)

MacLeish used as his inspiration the famous Benet story (required reading when I was in grade school) in which Webster (Patrick Magee) acts as a defense lawyer for the farmer Jabez Stone (Will Mackenzie) when the devil, called Scratch (Will Geer), comes to claim the man’s soul in return for having made his farm prosperous. The jury, selected by Scratch, is an assortment of the ghosts of notorious villains and rogues. In the MacLeish telling, Webster himself becomes the victim, rather than Stone. (Stone? Hmm. How curious.)

Roy Poole, Patrick Magee.

Cast members included Roy Poole, Rex Robbins, Joanne Nail, and Thomas Barbour.

Martin Gottfried said it was “empty and archaic,” excessively high flown, and “a disaster, boring beyond belief.” Jack Kroll condemned it as “an inflated and disastrously abstract play ,“ while Clive Barnes discarded it as “a ponderous piece . . . pedestrianly written . . . raising pseudo-moral issues that it answers with a kind of chop-logic.” 

On second thought, perhaps it would be better to ponder an updating than to try actually doing one.

Sunday, January 31, 2021

457. SCORE. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.

Michael Beirne,, Claire Wilbur, Lynn Swann, Sylvester E. Stallone.
SCORE [Comedy/Homosexuality/Marriage/Sex] A/D: Jerry Douglas; S: T.E. Mason; L: Candace King; P: Michael Harvey; T: Martinique Theatre (OB); 10/28/70-11/15/70 (23)

Sylvester Stallone was still in the starving actor stage of his career (he was billed as Sylvester E. Stallone) when he appeared in the secondary role of Mike, a lusty phone repairman, in this comic embarrassment about sex-swapping. The New York Times’s review was headlined: “Nude Sex Play Opens at the Martinique.” Set in Queens, Score tells of a bisexual couple, Jack (Michael Beirne), a cheesecake photographer, and wife, Elvira (Claire Wilbur), a concert pianist, who keep a competitive score of how many friends they can seduce within preset time limits.

An orgy transpires with Betsy (Lynn Swann, no, not the great football player), a Catholic lesbian inspired to say her first “God damn!” after enjoying the experience, and Eddie (Ben Wilson), an accountant who enjoys bowling. This product of the theatre’s so-called sexual liberation in the early 70s offered nudity and pot-smoking aplenty, with a good deal of simulated love making.

The show was forced by an Off-Broadway actors’ strike to close early, but its reviews offered little promise of continued interest. Mel Gussow concluded his review by saying, “Superficially there is a certain professionalism in this production. The lights work. The acting is not all bad. And there is even a tinny laugh or two. But beneath the pseudo-sophisticated surface, the play is not very different from a pornographic paperback. Except that the price of tickets runs as high as $10.”

In 1974, the play was made into a pornographic movie, described in this Wikipedia article, which also throws some light on the play.

 

Saturday, January 30, 2021

456. THE SCHOOL FOR WIVES. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.


Brian Bedford, Joan Van Ark.
THE SCHOOL FOR WIVES [Dramatic Revival] A: Molière; TR: Richard Wilbur; D: Stephen Porter; S/L: James Tilton; C: Nancy Potts; M: Conrad Susa; P: Phoenix Theatre; T: Lyceum Theatre; 2/16/71-5/29/71 (120)

Never before produced on Broadway in English, Molière’s L’École des Femmes was provided with an outstanding production under Stephen Porter’s clever directorial guidance. Brian Bedford received accolades for his inimitable performance as Arnolphe, an aging and jealous gentleman married to Agnes (Joan Van Ark). She is the sweet young thing he wishes to protect from younger suitors by shielding her from their gaze.

David Dukes, Brian Bedford, Peggy Pope, James Greene, Joan Van Ark.

The complications that ensue when his friend, the dashing young Horace (David Dukes) falls in love with and tries to woo Agnes, without knowing her relationship to Arnolphe, offer the basis for this comedy of cuckoldry.

Translator Richard Wilbur’s sprightly rhymed couplets, said the delighted Richard Watts, roll “off the tongue with such idiomatic ease that is [sic] sounds for all the world like an English classic.” Most observers thought the humor and charm were on a par with the best Broadway entertainment, considering the company mettlesome, and the direction warm, zestful, and human. A rare detractor was Brendan Gill, who deemed this a “conscientious” but essentially joyless revival. Despite valiant efforts, he observed, “the play has slipped through their over-careful fingers.” Commenting on the title, he stated that it should be translated without the definite article.

James Greene, Brian Bedford, Peggy Pope.

Bedford, an admired English actor who often starred on Broadway in British plays (especially the classics), was, to many, the show’s best feature. Douglas Watt felt he gave “a smashing comedy performance” in which he “seizes the part and plays it as the young Charles Laughton might have done, but in his own special style. His rages are heartfelt and passionately presented. . . . It is a sweeping, majestic comic performance that often succeeds in arousing our sympathy for this superior fellow whose ill luck it is to be confounded by ninnies.” To T.E. Kalem Bedford was “a comic marvel. His face is an ever-changing panorama of unholy glee, bottomless despair, and a sour-pickle sneer.” Among the few sourly sneering responses, however, was that of Stanley Kauffmann, who found Bedford mannered and unconvincing.

George Pentecost, Brian Bedford.

Barnes added, "The two other leading actors, the flourishing Horace of David Dukes and the radiantly innocent Agnes of Joan van [sic] Ark, show just the right panache, also giving the play the verve and sparkle it demands."

Bedford walked off with the Tony for Best Actor, Play, and the Drama Desk Award for Outstanding Performance. Van Ark received a Tony nomination for Best Supporting Actress, Play, and a Theatre World Award.


 

Friday, January 29, 2021

455. THE SCHOOL FOR SCANDAL. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.

David Ogden Stiers, Patti LuPone.
THE SCHOOL FOR SCANDAL [Dramatic Revival] A: Richard Brinsley Sheridan; D: Gerald Freedman; S: Douglas W. Schmidt; C: John David Ridge; L: Joe Pacitti; M: Robert Waldman; P: City Center Acting Company; T: Good Shepherd-Faith Church (OB); 9/27/72-10/28/72 (12) 

The School for Scandal was revived in repertory with five other plays by the youthful Acting Company in their first professional season. The overall quality of their work bore a fragrance of talented amateurism, but the troupe, not long after being trained at Juilliard, succeeded in offering considerable promise, which many company members fulfilled. 

David Ogden Stiers represented the evening’s strongest work in the role of Joseph Surface, and there were good notices for what T.E. Kalem called Patti LuPone’s performance as Lady Teazle, the “interesting,” Lady Sneerwell of Mary Lou Rosato, as John Simon put it, and, in Clive Barnes’s words, the “bluffly likable" Charles of Kevin Kline. (Rosato was commended by the Drama Desk as Most Promising Performer.)The church-theatre venue was uncomfortable, though, and the thrust stage served little purpose when no seats were able to surround it. 

Gerald Freedman’s staging of the heavily cut 1777 comedy of manners was spirited, but needed more eye-catching movement patterns. On the whole, the actors were still far from commanding the sense of period demanded, and the result for many, as for Walter Kerr, smacked too strongly of “a graduation exercise.”