Wednesday, February 10, 2021

LEITER LOOKS BACK: FIVE REVIVALS OF 1924-1925

Katherine Cornell in Candida.

For the latest installment of my series, "Leiter Looks Back," this one covering revivals of 1924-1925, please click on THEATER PIZZAZZ.

467. SGT. PEPPER'S LONELY HEARTS CLUB BAND ON THE ROAD. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.

Kay Cole. (Photos: Michael Childers.)

SGT, PEPPER’S LONELY HEARTS CLUB BAND ON THE ROAD [Musical/Romance/Show Business/Youth] CN/AD: Robin Wagner and Tom O’Horgan; M/LY: John Lennon and Paul McCartney; D: Tom O’Horgan; S: Robin Wagner, Randy Barcelo; L: Jules Fisher; P: Robert Stigwood i/a/w Brian Avnet and Scarab Productions, Inc.; T: Beacon Theatre; 11/17/74-1/5/75 (66)

Ted Neeley, Alaina Reed, and company.

The gargantuan proclivities of theatricalist director Tom O’Horgan grew ever more tiresome to the critics in the mid-70s. His work hit a low point with this juke box musical, described by Mel Gussow as an “inflated production” suffering from “elephantiasis.” Produced at a large, Upper West Side venue formerly a movie house but increasingly used for concerts and special events, it attempted to animate the stage with a psychedelic interpretation of the Beatles’ popular 1967 rock music album.

The original 12 songs on the “Sergeant Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club” disc were supplemented by 17 additional Lennon-McCartney numbers. To meld the disparate songs into a unity of sorts, a transparent plot was grafted onto the score, but the glue failed to hold and the pieces fell apart.

O’Horgan’s fragile, dialogue-less book tells of how the ambitious young rock star Billy Shears (Ted Neeley) is corrupted through the machinations of the three contract-bearing, androgynously-dressed Hammermen (Allan Nicholls, William Parry, and B.G. Gibson). This group that seemed to Martin Gottfried “to represent the show’s point that the business end of pop music killed the Beatles.” Along the way, Billy’s romance with Strawberry Fields (Kay Cole) and temptation by Lucy (Alaina Reed, who received the best reviews) are also depicted.

The clichéd story was expressed through Robin Wagner’s spectacular props and Jules Fisher’s extravagant lighting. Huge, white balloons on which slides could be projected; gigantic puppets, including a hand that danced; an octopus; an enormous jar of mustard; and a 20-foot tall Statue of Liberty were among the scenic elements that led T.E. Kalem to accuse the show of being ill with “the metastasis of spectacle over substance.” He was angry at how the excellent music had been “trampled under the dreck of Tom O’Horgan’s grimagination,” and called the show a “decadent nightmare.”

Gottfried thought Sgt. Pepper “a clumsy concert with dance movement and Thanksgiving parade props. It is leaden and cheap,” while Gussow reiterated how little of anything new had been contributed from the “attic” of O’Horgan’s creativity.

In addition to the title song, the playlist included "With a Little Help from my Friends," "Nowhere Man," "Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds," "I Want You," "Come Together," "Sun Queen," "Lovely Rita," "Polythene Pam," "She Came in through the Bathroom Window," "You Never Give Me Your Money," "Her Majesty," "A Day in the Life," "She's Leaving Home," "Strawberry Fields Forever," "Getting Better," "Because," "When I'm 64," "Good Morning, Good Morning," "Being for the Benefit of Mr. Kite," "Oh, Darling," "Fixing a Hole," "Mean Mr. Mustard," "Maxwell's Silver Hammer," "Carry that Weight," "Golden Slumbers," "The Long and Winding Road," and "Get Back."

Tuesday, February 9, 2021

466. SENSATIONS. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.

Marie Santell, John Savage, Joe Masiell. (Photos: Barry Kramer)

SENSATIONS [Musical/Drugs/Romance/Youth] B/LY: Paul Zakrzweski; M: Wally Harper; SC: Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet; D: Jerry Dodge; S: William and Jean Eckart; C: Jeanne Button; L: Beverly Emmons; P: John Bowab and Charles Celian; T: Theatre Four (OB): 10/25/70-11/8/70 (16)

John Savage, Judy Gibson.

One of a flood of youth-oriented rock musicals that hit the Big Apple in the 70s, Sensations had what was widely considered a fine score. Edith Oliver called the songs “delightful,” and Mel Gussow gushed: “Wally Harper has written one of the best rock show scores I have ever heard—complex, richly textured, even hummable— a perfect answer to anyone who thinks rock is not melodic. Besides those ballads there are three terrific pro test songs—and much more.”

But it was wasted on an uneven, misconceived attempt to place the Romeo and Juliet story within a contemporary environment. Unlike West Side Story, the epitome of musical adaptations of the same material, it failed to effect a happy marriage between the Bard and the modern world. Gussow, who found nuggets to enjoy, pointed to the show's claim that it was "suggested" by Romeo and Juliet, asking, "What suggestion? This is no mere rock updating, but a complete overhaul!" 

The show was filled with topical references—drugs, race relations, sex, war, pollution, and so on. As in not a few modern productions (as, for example, the 2013 Broadway production starring Orlando Bloom and Condola Rashid), Romeo (John Savage), was white and Juliet (Judy Gibson)—despite white parents—black. Capulet (James Ray) was impotent and Lady Capulet (Paulette Attie) "a bitch in heat." The Friar (Arthur Bartow) was played like a red-nosed burlesque comic. He even sang a little ditty that went, "Masturbation, fellatio, bestiality, vodeododo" (Hair, of course, had beat him to it.)

A gay Mercutio (Bruce Scott) and Tybalt (Ron Martin), the latter also incestuously inclined toward Lady Capulet, and various other campy ideas, led Martin Gottfried to compare the work to that of the Ridiculous Theatrical Company. Oliver snapped that it was “a fumbling attempt (and an extraordinarily disagreeable one, for all its fervor),” “a fatuous charade.” And Arthur Sainer rapped it as “pure bullshit, long on décor, short on heart.”

In John Savage, Sensations provided a boyishly attractive young actor who would have, if not a sensational career, several years in which his star shone bright. Still, his performance left much to be desired, Gussow stating that "he looks dyspeptic as Romeo, and plays his Shakespearean lines weakly."

Monday, February 8, 2021

465. THE SELLING OF THE PRESIDENT. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.

Pat Hingle, Barbara Barrie. (Photo: Martha Swope.)
THE SELLING OF THE PRESIDENT [Musical/Advertising/Politics] B: Jack O’Brien and Stuart Hample; M: Bob James; LY: Jack O’Brien; SC: Joe McGinniss’s book The Selling of the President; D: Robert H. Livingston; S: Tom H. John; C: Nancy Potts; L: Thomas Skelton; P: John Flaxman i/a/w Harold Hastings and Franklin Roberts; T: Sam S. Shubert Theatre; 3/22/72-3/25/72 (5)

Pat Hingle.

Plagued by preshow problems, including the departure of director Robert H. Livingston and book writer Stuart Hample, and their replacement by lyricist Jack O’Brien—as well as a lawsuit brought by Joe McGinniss claiming that the producers, heavily backed by someone connected with a pesticide company, had inserted commercials for their product into the show’s TV format—The Selling of the President couldn’t sell enough seats to last even a week. Of course, reviews like Walter Kerr’s, accusing the show of “staggering ineptitude,” weren’t very helpful.

This musical was based on a popular 1968 book about how President Nixon’s campaign first campaign had been manipulated by the media. The show, however, fictionalized the story by moving the action forward to 1976, calling the candidate George Mason (Pat Hingle), and setting the entire action within the confines of a TV studio from which Mason never departs during his entire successful campaign. Nixon was still in office when the show opened.

Cast members of note included Barbara Barrie, Karen Morrow, and TV personality Johnny Olson (as himself). And co-librettist/lyricist Jack O'Brien would find a more distinguished career helming instead of writing shows.

According to Clive Barnes, “the book is too weak, emasculated and inane to draw the political blood needed for it to survive.” The music was of similar quality. There was a smooth and effective use of multimedia techniques, including film, video, and projections, but, wrote Julius Novick “the show suffered from a lack of courage . . . , imagination and wit.”

Sunday, February 7, 2021

464. SEESAW. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.


Ken Howard, Michelle Lee.
SEESAW [Musical/Romance] B/D/CH: Michael Bennett; C0-CH: Grover Dale; M: Cy Coleman; LY: Dorothy Fields; SC: William Gibson’s play, Two for the Seesaw; S: Robin Wagner; C: Ann Roth; L: Jules Fisher; P: Joseph Kipness and Lawrence Kasha; James Nederlander, George M. Steinbrenner III, and Lorin E. Price; T: Uris Theatre; 3/18/73-12/8/73 (296)

Michelle Lee, Giancarlo Esposito, John Gavin, Cecilia Norfleet, and company.

Seesaw was an enjoyable, far from remarkable, musical based on a popular two-character play of 1962 that had starred Henry Fonda and Anne Bancroft, each of whom was considered ideal for their roles. It concerns a love affair between a Jewish girl from the Bronx, Gittel Mosca (Michelle Lee), and a square, WASP lawyer from Nebraska, Jerry Ryan (Ken Howard; replaced by John Gavin).

Judy Gibson, Michon Peacock, Baayork Lee, Anita Morris.

The musical remake was written, directed, and choreographed by Michael Bennett, a couple of years before he became Broadway’s hottest creative commodity with A Chorus Line. Bennett’s libretto opened up the story considerably to allow for new characters and exterior scenes. The original had shown only Jerry’s apartment on one side of the stage and Gittel’s on the other. A new scene, aimed at bringing the life of New York City into the show more dynamically, was set at a mobile theatre’s Spanish-language street production of Hamlet.

Tommy Tune.

Seesaw was rather faithful to William Gibson’s script in its depiction of the romance between the lovable, ulcerous, pathetic wait Gittel, who wants to be a dancer, but is mired in her life as a seamstress, and Jerry, the married man who desires her, but can’t pull free of his Omaha wife, to whom he eventually returns.

Michelle Lee, John Gavin

Some, like Clive Barnes, liked much of Seesaw, but had strong reservations as well. Barnes appreciated the book (“literate and interesting”), was less well-disposed toward the “tuneful but not especially memorable” music by the distinguished Cy Coleman, and felt likewise about the equally distinguished Dorothy Fields’s lyrics, which he described as “deft enough but [they] seem to have more dexterity than lyricism.” Brendan Gill was irked by the way the book “shuttled” the spectator back and forth between the two principals,” and John Simon felt the broadened scope diluted the impact of Gibson’s cozy world. “Worse: the additional characters and situations are trivially observed and glibly slapped on. . . . [T]he book remains an untimely hodgepodge.” Yet Walter Kerr called Seesaw “a love of a show that knows just when to keep the pressure low and when to open up.” He asserted that "the evening’s end now seems more necessary and more moving than it did in the original play.”

Greater homogeneity of opinion greeted Robin Wagner’s splendid scene designs and Sheppard Kerman’s cityscape projections. Also admired was the effective, abundant, and inventive Bennett choreography (developed with several assistants and co-choreographer Grover Dale); the warmth and charm of Michelle Lee’s Gittel; and the stolid, supportive Jerry of Ken Howard. However, what may have been the show’s principal contribution to Broadway was an attractive, young 6’6” dancer from Texas named Tommy Tune. Tune’s performance as David, a gay choreographer, practically stole the show during his dance routines. “Tommy Tune, as long on talent as on legs, is an exquisitely animated beanpole as well as a gracefully sinuous vine,” gushed Simon.

Cast members of subsequent note included Giancarlo Esposito, Michon Peacock, Anita Morris, Cecilia Norfleet, Baayork Lee,

Giancarlo Esposito, Ken Howard, Michelle Lee.

The consensus was tersely expressed by Martin Gottfried: “The show isn’t great, but it works.” While it didn’t work well enough to turn a profit before closing, it did compile an impressive list of awards and nominations. The show itself was nominated for a Best Musical Tony, and Bennet was Tony-nominated for his book, direction, and choreography. Coleman and Fields were Tony-nominated for their score, while another Tony nomination went to Lee for Best Actress, Musical. Only Tune, though, actually won a Tony, for Best Supporting Actor, Musical. Lee won an award from the Outer Critics Circle, and a Drama Desk Award for Outstanding Performance. And Robin Wagner garnered a Joseph Maharam Foundation Award.

Saturday, February 6, 2021

463. THE SECRET AFFAIRS OF MILDRED WILD. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.



Doris Roberts, Elizabeth Wilson, Florence Stanley, Maureen Stapleton, Neil Flanagan, Joan Pape, Lee Wallace.
THE SECRET AFFAIRS OF MILDRED WILD [Comedy/Fantasy/Films] A: Paul Zindel; D: Jeff Bleckner; S: Santo Loquasto; C: Carrie F. Robbins; L: Thomas Skelton; P: James B. McKenzie and Spofford J. Beadle; T: Ambassador Theatre; 11/14/72-12/2/72 (23)

Maureen Stapleton, Neil Flanagan.

The critics bulldozed a wide path through this insubstantial comedy about Mildred Wild (Maureen Stapleton), a middle-aged film fanatic, who escapes from the humdrum prosaicness of her life as the wife of a diabetic, Greenwich Village candy store owner (Lee Wallace) by imagining herself the heroine of old Hollywood movies. She watches at least 3,000 movies a year and has collected fan magazines since the 1920s. Mildred’s fantasies allow her to be Shirley Temple, Scarlett O’Hara, King Kong’s main squeeze, Tarzan’s Jane, and Ginger Rogers. The shallow plotline establishes her as the winner of a phony contest that would presumably send her to Hollywood for a screen test.

Lee Wallace, Doris Roberts, Maureen Stapleton.

Stapleton’s talents were capably exhibited in the broadly played, quick-change, Walter Mitty-ish leading role, but her performance lacked a play in which to flourish. As Jack Kroll observed of playwright Paul Zindel, “He has written so far down to the audience that he’s fallen right through it and is at this moment plummeting straight to hell. . . . I have never seen such a symphony of gangrenous venality as this play.”

Elizabeth Wilson, Lee Wallace, Maureen Stapleton.

Clive Barnes wrote that “Miss Stapleton . . . runs the gamut as a crushed cauliflower about to blossom, and her accomplishment as a comedienne is precise and beautiful. She always exaggerates with taste. . . . But Miss Stapleton is not a stand-up comic. Too often the author has supplied her with wisecracks rather than a character, and with situations rather than a play.” Florence Stanley, Elizabeth Wilson, Neil Flanagan, and Doris Roberts, were among the fine actors who were unable to make this turkey edible.

Lee Wallace, Maureen Stapleton.

Friday, February 5, 2021

462. SEASCAPE. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.



Maureen Anderman, Frank Langella.

SEASCAPE [Comedy/Animals/Fantasy/Marriage/Sex] A/D: Edward Albee; S/L: James Tilton; C: Fred Voelpel; P: Richard Barr, Charles Woodward, Clinton Wilder; T: Sam S. Shubert Theatre; 1/26/75-3/22/75 (65)

Deborah Kerr, Barry Nelson.

Edward Albee won the Pulitzer Prize for this fanciful allegory, but few critics would have supported the decision to grant him the award, even though Clive Barnes’s Times review was headlined: “Seascape Is a Major Event.”

Nancy (Deborah Kerr) and Charlie (Barry Nelson) are attractive, youngish grandparents lounging on a beach and discussing life both in general and in particular. Every now and then a military jet roars overhead. Ennui has settled in. Charlie’s main ambition is to do nothing. Nancy’s is to go from one beach to another around the world. He recalls his secret teenage habit of sinking to the sea’s bottom, stones in his hands, and remaining there as long as possible. Their relationship is passive; sex is in retirement. Their kids have grown up and left the nest. An air of mild acrimony mars their discourse.

Maureen Anderman, Frank Langella, Deborah Kerr, Barry Nelson.

Then, as act one nears its end, a pair of strangers enters: two huge lizards with powerful lashing tails. The husband lizard is Leslie (Frank Langella), the wife Sarah (Maureen Anderman). They speak a highly educated-sounding English. Leslie and Sarah have come up from the sea for a breath of air and soon they and Nancy and Charlie are conversing about the differences between amphibian and human sex organs, married life, and so on.

Charlie almost frightens the reptilian pair back into the ocean with his comments about death, but this hurdle is cleared and Leslie and Sarah are convinced to remain on land and participate in their evolutionary duties. The play closes on Leslie’s tag: “Begin.” (Do I hear an echo of this at the end of Angels in America?)

 Barnes was the play's strongest supporter. Seascape, he wrote, is “a curiously compelling exploration into the basic tenets of life” in which “the tone of the writing is always thoughtful, even careful, even philosophic,” thereby helping to create “a play of great density, with many emotional and intellectual reverberations.” Bleaker opinions prevailed, however, as in Douglas Watt’s belief that there was “nothing especially stimulating about the occasion.” He thought the language was “more literary than dramatic. . . . The dialogue is urbane, occasionally witty, but stiff and artificial-sounding.” This view was shared by many.

“Albee seems drained of almost all vitality—theatrical, intellectual, artistic,” griped Jack Kroll, while John Simon called Seascape a work of “doughy verbiage, feebly quivering inaction, and grandly gesticulating pretentiousness.” 

The play’s meaning was disputed, Simon, for instance, saying that the lizards could represent “underprivileged minorities, upward mobility, élan vital . . . ; the human beings . . . the bourgeoisie, the declining West, the Establishment.”

Whatever its meaning, Seascape went under in two months.

Seascape was Albee’s first stab at directing his plays on Broadway; there was little argument over the acceptable quality of his staging. Movie star Deborah Kerr (returning to Broadway after a long absence) and Barry Nelson (one of Broadway's most reliable leading men) gave their usual high-quality performances, but the actors playing the creatures captured the most attention, especially Langella in his Broadway debut. His reptilian movements and expressive voice, despite his being encased in a costume covering him from head to foot, stole the show, as Watt declared. 

Barnes had this to say of Langella and Anderman:

To my amazement I note from the playbill that this is Frank Langella's Broadway debut—he is among our most distinguished young actors, and Broadway should be ashamed of itself. It would be so easy to play a lizard as sort of Demon King or Godzilla, but Mr. Langella plays him precisely as one of those animals you have always longed to communicate with but never had the language. His partner, Maureen Anderman, is also superbly lizardlike, but as humanly feminine as Mr. Langella is humanly masculine.

In addition to the Pulitzer, Seascape won the Elizabeth Hull-Kate Warriner Award, and was nominated for a Tony. Langella won the Tony for Best Featured Actor, while garnering the Drama Desk Award for Supporting Actor. James Tilton was granted a Tony nomination for Best Lighting Designer.