Friday, February 12, 2021

469. SEXTET. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.

Harvey Evans, Mary Small, Robert Spenser, Dixie Carter, Jerry Lanning.
SEXTET [Musical/Homosexuality/Sex] B: Harvey Perr and Lee Goldsmith; M: Lawrence Hurwit: LY: Lee Goldsmith; D/CH: Jered Barclay; S: Peter Harvey; C: Zoe Brown; L: Marc B. Weiss; P: Balemar Productions, and Lawrence E. Sokol; T: Bijou Theatre; 3/3/74-3/10/74 (9)

An intimate six-character musical that many considered a derivative of the successful Stephen Sondheim-Hal Prince show Company, but without that classic’s finesse and genius. In Sextet, the characters are guests at a dinner party given by two gay men, Kenneth (Harvey Evans) and David (Robert Spencer). There are David’s stereotypical widowed Jewish mother, Fay (Mary Small), her salesman date, Paul (John Newton), David’s straight, ex-college roommate, Leonard (Jerry Lanning), and Leonard’s wife, Ann (Dixie Carter, who would have a successful career, including the TV series, “Designing Women”). As the evening progresses, the various sexual attitudes and feelings among the six are gradually disclosed.

“In the end,” Martin Gottfried commented, “they discover . . . that they’re stuck with who they are.” He also described how the show’s nonlinear construction allowed it to layer and mix the dialogue. “One character talks to a second, who responds to a third who reacts to a fourth.”

In turning thumbs down Clive Barnes remarked that the show suffered from a dearth of humor and, while pleasantly modest, a “faintly familiar” score. He cited a scene touched on by several others as the show’s funniest, when the square salesman smokes a joint and blows smoke rings with it. Edith Oliver called it a “frail little musical,” and Douglas Watt regarded it “more with pity than outright displeasure.” Richard Watts, however, called it “amiable and quite agreeable,” while Gottfried, the most positive reviewer, was captivated what he considered a “clever and straight and musical and funny and unusual and fine show.”

Like others, Barnes picked Carter as the standout performer: “I liked best Dixie Carter as Ann, because she looks pretty, plays a trumpet and does a Grouch Marx impersonation.”

FEBRUARY 12 IN THE 1940S: ON THIS DAY IN NEW YORK THEATER

Dorothy McGuire, Donald Cook, Frances Starr in Claudia.
For the latest installment fn my series, "On This Day in New York Theater," please click on THEATER LIFE.

Thursday, February 11, 2021

468. 70, GIRLS, 70. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.

Gil Lamb, Mildred Natwick, Hans Conreid.
70, GIRLS, 70 [Musical/Crime/Old Age] B: F,red Ebb and Norman L. Martin (AD: Joe Masteroff); M: John Kander; LY: Fred Ebb; D: Paul Aaron; CH: Onna White; S/L: Robert Randolph; C: Jane Greenwood; P: Arthur Whitelaw i/a/w Seth Harrison; T: Broadhurst Theatre; 4/15/71-5/15/71 (36)

Jay Velie, Coley Worth, Lillian Roth, Thomas Anderson, Joey Faye.

One of several 1970s shows that focused on elderly people, 70, Girls, 70 had a plot that reflected that of the movie Make Mine Mink (although not credited as such). A group of septuagenarians residing in a seedy Upper West Side retirement hotel are inspired by one of their number (Mildred Natwick) to become a gang of shop-lifting thieves. Natwick’s character eventually is caught and dies. She returns for the finale, however, seated on a crescent moon in heaven. (No, she did not say, "The Great Work Begins.")

Most of the cast was Social Security-eligible, but one reviewer thought Natwick, 66, looked too young for her role. She was good enough, however, to earn a Tony nomination for Best Actress, Musical. Supporting her were names such as Hans Conreid, Sally De May, Henrietta Jacobson, Lillian Roth, Joey Faye, Tommy Breslin, Coley Worth, Lucie Lancaster, Jay Velie, among others.

Coley Worth, Lucie Lancaster, Mildred Natwick, Joey Faye.

Reviews were mixed, but no one was over that crescent moon for it. Harold Clurman shook his head at this “loony, corny, untidy affair,” yet noted that it had “a freshness of feeling, . . . an elation of craftsmanship. . . . One must be marvelously uptight not to enjoy the fling.” Clive Barnes also had reservations, but appreciated the show’s “refreshingly unsentimental attitude to . . . the aged,” its occasionally “bright music and lyrics, and “natural warmth and happiness.”

The downside carried the day, however. Douglas Watt, for one, called the show “about as enlivening an affair as a New Year’s Eve party thrown by the members of the St. Petersburg shuffle board club.” Martin Gottfried even walked out, claiming it was “the sloppiest musical” he had ever seen.

Henrietta Jacobson, Tommy Breslin.

Kander and Ebb, the score writers, were already Broadway stars, especially for Cabaret. Here they offered 15 songs, some of their titles being “Old Folks,” “Broadway, My Street,” “The Caper,” “Hit It, Lorraine,” “Boom, Ditty Boom,” “70, Girls, 70,” and “Yes.” Most are still known mainly by show biz geeks, who appear--from initial reactions to this entry--to be more abundant than one might have imagined.

Wednesday, February 10, 2021

LEITER LOOKS BACK: FIVE REVIVALS OF 1924-1925

Katherine Cornell in Candida.

For the latest installment of my series, "Leiter Looks Back," this one covering revivals of 1924-1925, please click on THEATER PIZZAZZ.

467. SGT. PEPPER'S LONELY HEARTS CLUB BAND ON THE ROAD. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.

Kay Cole. (Photos: Michael Childers.)

SGT, PEPPER’S LONELY HEARTS CLUB BAND ON THE ROAD [Musical/Romance/Show Business/Youth] CN/AD: Robin Wagner and Tom O’Horgan; M/LY: John Lennon and Paul McCartney; D: Tom O’Horgan; S: Robin Wagner, Randy Barcelo; L: Jules Fisher; P: Robert Stigwood i/a/w Brian Avnet and Scarab Productions, Inc.; T: Beacon Theatre; 11/17/74-1/5/75 (66)

Ted Neeley, Alaina Reed, and company.

The gargantuan proclivities of theatricalist director Tom O’Horgan grew ever more tiresome to the critics in the mid-70s. His work hit a low point with this juke box musical, described by Mel Gussow as an “inflated production” suffering from “elephantiasis.” Produced at a large, Upper West Side venue formerly a movie house but increasingly used for concerts and special events, it attempted to animate the stage with a psychedelic interpretation of the Beatles’ popular 1967 rock music album.

The original 12 songs on the “Sergeant Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club” disc were supplemented by 17 additional Lennon-McCartney numbers. To meld the disparate songs into a unity of sorts, a transparent plot was grafted onto the score, but the glue failed to hold and the pieces fell apart.

O’Horgan’s fragile, dialogue-less book tells of how the ambitious young rock star Billy Shears (Ted Neeley) is corrupted through the machinations of the three contract-bearing, androgynously-dressed Hammermen (Allan Nicholls, William Parry, and B.G. Gibson). This group that seemed to Martin Gottfried “to represent the show’s point that the business end of pop music killed the Beatles.” Along the way, Billy’s romance with Strawberry Fields (Kay Cole) and temptation by Lucy (Alaina Reed, who received the best reviews) are also depicted.

The clichéd story was expressed through Robin Wagner’s spectacular props and Jules Fisher’s extravagant lighting. Huge, white balloons on which slides could be projected; gigantic puppets, including a hand that danced; an octopus; an enormous jar of mustard; and a 20-foot tall Statue of Liberty were among the scenic elements that led T.E. Kalem to accuse the show of being ill with “the metastasis of spectacle over substance.” He was angry at how the excellent music had been “trampled under the dreck of Tom O’Horgan’s grimagination,” and called the show a “decadent nightmare.”

Gottfried thought Sgt. Pepper “a clumsy concert with dance movement and Thanksgiving parade props. It is leaden and cheap,” while Gussow reiterated how little of anything new had been contributed from the “attic” of O’Horgan’s creativity.

In addition to the title song, the playlist included "With a Little Help from my Friends," "Nowhere Man," "Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds," "I Want You," "Come Together," "Sun Queen," "Lovely Rita," "Polythene Pam," "She Came in through the Bathroom Window," "You Never Give Me Your Money," "Her Majesty," "A Day in the Life," "She's Leaving Home," "Strawberry Fields Forever," "Getting Better," "Because," "When I'm 64," "Good Morning, Good Morning," "Being for the Benefit of Mr. Kite," "Oh, Darling," "Fixing a Hole," "Mean Mr. Mustard," "Maxwell's Silver Hammer," "Carry that Weight," "Golden Slumbers," "The Long and Winding Road," and "Get Back."

Tuesday, February 9, 2021

466. SENSATIONS. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.

Marie Santell, John Savage, Joe Masiell. (Photos: Barry Kramer)

SENSATIONS [Musical/Drugs/Romance/Youth] B/LY: Paul Zakrzweski; M: Wally Harper; SC: Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet; D: Jerry Dodge; S: William and Jean Eckart; C: Jeanne Button; L: Beverly Emmons; P: John Bowab and Charles Celian; T: Theatre Four (OB): 10/25/70-11/8/70 (16)

John Savage, Judy Gibson.

One of a flood of youth-oriented rock musicals that hit the Big Apple in the 70s, Sensations had what was widely considered a fine score. Edith Oliver called the songs “delightful,” and Mel Gussow gushed: “Wally Harper has written one of the best rock show scores I have ever heard—complex, richly textured, even hummable— a perfect answer to anyone who thinks rock is not melodic. Besides those ballads there are three terrific pro test songs—and much more.”

But it was wasted on an uneven, misconceived attempt to place the Romeo and Juliet story within a contemporary environment. Unlike West Side Story, the epitome of musical adaptations of the same material, it failed to effect a happy marriage between the Bard and the modern world. Gussow, who found nuggets to enjoy, pointed to the show's claim that it was "suggested" by Romeo and Juliet, asking, "What suggestion? This is no mere rock updating, but a complete overhaul!" 

The show was filled with topical references—drugs, race relations, sex, war, pollution, and so on. As in not a few modern productions (as, for example, the 2013 Broadway production starring Orlando Bloom and Condola Rashid), Romeo (John Savage), was white and Juliet (Judy Gibson)—despite white parents—black. Capulet (James Ray) was impotent and Lady Capulet (Paulette Attie) "a bitch in heat." The Friar (Arthur Bartow) was played like a red-nosed burlesque comic. He even sang a little ditty that went, "Masturbation, fellatio, bestiality, vodeododo" (Hair, of course, had beat him to it.)

A gay Mercutio (Bruce Scott) and Tybalt (Ron Martin), the latter also incestuously inclined toward Lady Capulet, and various other campy ideas, led Martin Gottfried to compare the work to that of the Ridiculous Theatrical Company. Oliver snapped that it was “a fumbling attempt (and an extraordinarily disagreeable one, for all its fervor),” “a fatuous charade.” And Arthur Sainer rapped it as “pure bullshit, long on décor, short on heart.”

In John Savage, Sensations provided a boyishly attractive young actor who would have, if not a sensational career, several years in which his star shone bright. Still, his performance left much to be desired, Gussow stating that "he looks dyspeptic as Romeo, and plays his Shakespearean lines weakly."

Monday, February 8, 2021

465. THE SELLING OF THE PRESIDENT. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975.

Pat Hingle, Barbara Barrie. (Photo: Martha Swope.)
THE SELLING OF THE PRESIDENT [Musical/Advertising/Politics] B: Jack O’Brien and Stuart Hample; M: Bob James; LY: Jack O’Brien; SC: Joe McGinniss’s book The Selling of the President; D: Robert H. Livingston; S: Tom H. John; C: Nancy Potts; L: Thomas Skelton; P: John Flaxman i/a/w Harold Hastings and Franklin Roberts; T: Sam S. Shubert Theatre; 3/22/72-3/25/72 (5)

Pat Hingle.

Plagued by preshow problems, including the departure of director Robert H. Livingston and book writer Stuart Hample, and their replacement by lyricist Jack O’Brien—as well as a lawsuit brought by Joe McGinniss claiming that the producers, heavily backed by someone connected with a pesticide company, had inserted commercials for their product into the show’s TV format—The Selling of the President couldn’t sell enough seats to last even a week. Of course, reviews like Walter Kerr’s, accusing the show of “staggering ineptitude,” weren’t very helpful.

This musical was based on a popular 1968 book about how President Nixon’s campaign first campaign had been manipulated by the media. The show, however, fictionalized the story by moving the action forward to 1976, calling the candidate George Mason (Pat Hingle), and setting the entire action within the confines of a TV studio from which Mason never departs during his entire successful campaign. Nixon was still in office when the show opened.

Cast members of note included Barbara Barrie, Karen Morrow, and TV personality Johnny Olson (as himself). And co-librettist/lyricist Jack O'Brien would find a more distinguished career helming instead of writing shows.

According to Clive Barnes, “the book is too weak, emasculated and inane to draw the political blood needed for it to survive.” The music was of similar quality. There was a smooth and effective use of multimedia techniques, including film, video, and projections, but, wrote Julius Novick “the show suffered from a lack of courage . . . , imagination and wit.”