Saturday, August 1, 2020

255. IN CASE OF ACCIDENT. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

Michael Shannon, Joseph Boley, Fay Sappington, Henderson Forsythe, Patricia Elliott, Terry Kiser.

IN CASE OF ACCIDENT [Drama/Art/Friendship] A: Peter Simon; D: Ted Cornell; S: John Scheffler; C: David James; L: Marc B. Weiss; P: William Craver; T: Eastside Playhouse (OB); 3/27/72-4/2/72 (8)

Some topflight acting talent was aboard this sinking ship that went down after its first week. Nearly every critic agreed that dramatist Peter Simon was a Harold Pinter copycat, but without the British master’s talent to sustain the style. As John Simon, himself no Pinter fan, cracked, “If there’s anything we do not need in the theatre it is pint-sized Pinter.”

In an upstate New York farmhouse, an ill young artist (Michael Shannon; no, not the current star of that name) has been seeking refuge for the past two months from the emotional and social frictions of his city environment. An old couple (Fay Sappington and Joseph Boley) are caring for him. Three of his New York friends—his girlfriend (Patricia Elliott), a former school teacher (Henderson Forsythe), and an effete art dealer (Terry Kiser)—find him out and try to get him to return home. Finally, following a car accident in which the friends are involved en route back to New York, he agrees to leave for the city.

The “play is about as inviting as a gin-and-bitters with a spoonful of Ivory Flakes added,” sneered Michael Feingold. Clive Barnes commented on the “stilted” quality and its pretentiousness, while Simon attacked the “meaningless conversations” and “painstaking outlandishness” of this “inscrutable concoction.”