Wednesday, July 15, 2020

218. GYPSY. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

Lisa Peluso, Angela Lansbury, Bonnie Langsford.
GYPSY [Musical Revival] B/D: Arthur Laurents; M: Jule Styne; LY: Stephen Sondheim; CH: Robert Tucker [using Jerome Robbins’s original choreography]; S/L: Robert Randolph; C: Raoul Pene du Bois (Angela Lansbury’s costumes by Robert Mackintosh); P: Barry M. Brown, Edgard Lansbury, Fritz Holt, and Joseph Beruh; T: Winter Garden; 9/23/74-1/4/75 (120)

Angela Lansbury.
A limited engagement of the 1959 classic musical comedy based on stripper Gypsy Rose Lee’s memoirs, this revival was first seen in London—to critical acclaim—and brought to Broadway with several of that production’s leads intact. These included Angela Lansbury as Rose, Zan Charisse as Gypsy, and Bonnie Langford as Baby June. The production, directed by the book’s author, meticulously recreated Jerome Robbins’s original dance numbers under Robert Tucker’s guidance, and Raoul Pene du Bois’s 1959 costumes were similarly back on view.

Zan Charisse.
Gypsy proved a smashing success to several critics. Walter Kerr claimed that is seemed “as entertainment and as craftsmanship . . . as dazzling as it was on the day it was so felicitously born.” Clive Barnes raved that “it is the kind of revival we cannot have too much of. Everything about Gypsy is right.” But Edith Oliver admitted, glumly, “everyone else . . . likes it more than I do,” and she proceeded to pan the “unremittingly self-centered” character of Rose as being too inhuman to enjoy. John Simon admitted to a great fondness for the material, but noted that it was almost, but not quite, hidden by “the somewhat humdrum staff of this production.” For Simon, the show’s “darker implications” were missing.

Mary Louise Wilson, Zan Charisse, Angela Lansbury.
The reviewers were generally lavish in their praise of Angela Lansbury’s Rose as an acting feat of major proportions. Barnes called her “enchanting, tragic, bewildering and bewildered.” John Beaufort said she gave “a whirlwind, dynamic performance that is both hilarious and moving.” The most remarked on feature of her work was the dimension of humanity, sensitivity, and vulnerability she gave to what is often considered a monstrously arrogant woman. Oliver, indeed, felt that Lansbury had played a role not invented by Laurents. Her big weakness was her inadequate vocal range and quality. In this, Ethel Merman, who originated the part, was, of course, light years ahead of her (and of practically anyone else attempting a Merman role). Many readers will no doubt immediately think of Rosalind Russell’s vocally problematic performance in the movie version.

The show snared a Tony win for Lansbury as Best Actress, Musical; a Tony nomination for Laurents as Best Director, Musical; a Drama Desk Award for Lansbury for Outstanding Performance; a similar award for Laurents for Outstanding Direction; and a Theatre World Award for Zan Charisse.