Saturday, August 1, 2020

256. IN GAY COMPANY. From my (unpublished) ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE NEW YORK STAGE, 1970-1975

Gordon Ramsey, Ann Hodapp, Robert Tananis.

IN GAY COMPANY [Musical Revue/Homosexuality] M/LY: Fred Silver; D: Sue Lawless; DS: Michael J. Hottopp, Paul dePass; P: MCB Company; T: Upstairs at Jimmy’s (OB); 4/4/75-4/13/75 (13)

A promising Off-Off Broadway show (at the Little Hippodrome, October 29, 1974) prompted an Off-Broadway move for this “try-sexual musical revue,” but, despite decent notices, it was gone before two weeks passed. Called simply Gay Company in its first appearance, the show had a definite appeal even though its subject matter limited its audiences to what Howard Thompson described as “intelligent adults with a sophisticated sense of humor who are fed up with sex exploitation and somewhat shabby counterparts to this show.”

Reviewing the Off-Off version, Thompson said the four-man, one-woman entertainment, which commented on male same-sex relationships within a program of 16 songs, was “tasteful and stylish,” and “lances social taboos with deadly irony.” The cast consisted of Rick Gardner, Bob Gorman, Ann Hodapp, Gordon Ramsey, and Robert Tananis.

The numbers each had a dramatic/comical core, as in the effective song that showed how aghast a quartet of macho Irish fire fighters would be if the fire department hired gay men. In another routine, two aging gays encounter each other after many years and fondly reminisce about their first meeting “At the Matachine Society Masquerade.”

Fred Silver’s two-piano score was “brilliantly conceived,” thought Thompson. John Simon also liked it, but found the sentimental ballads wanting. He commended the show, however, for handling its subject “without attitudinizing or special pleading.”